Read a sample: 1. The Climate Summit
We agree about the thermostat. This is important to establish before anyone makes accusations.
We agree that the house should be comfortable. We agree that neither of us should have to wear a winter coat indoors, and that perspiring while sitting still is a sign that something has gone wrong. We also agree that the thermostat is a useful device, although one of us believes it is useful primarily for setting the temperature, while the other believes it is useful for checking what the temperature has become.
Our difficulties arise in the modest territory between those positions.
I tend to run warm. My wife tends to be cold. These are not, as either of us has explained many times, matters of character. They are conditions we brought into the marriage, like our differing opinions about raisins and the proper number of towels to take on a weekend trip.
On a cool evening, I might walk into the living room and find her under a blanket, holding a mug in both hands.
“Are you cold?” I ask.
“No,” she says. “I have a blanket.”
This is a sound answer, but it leaves open the question of why the blanket was necessary in the first place. I look at the thermostat. The number seems reasonable to me. My wife looks at my feet.
“You’re not wearing socks,” she says.
“That’s because I’m not cold.”
“Yes,” she says. “I’ve noticed.”
From her position on the couch, my bare feet are evidence that the person responsible for setting the temperature has failed to use the equipment available to him. From mine, the blanket is evidence that a person who is cold can make herself warmer without altering the conditions for everybody else.
Neither argument wins. My wife points out that a blanket is excellent while sitting down but difficult to wear while making tea. I point out that socks are portable. She points out that she is already wearing socks.
At this stage I often discover that she is also wearing a sweater, which I had mentally classified as an outfit rather than protective gear.
We have learned to ask better questions. “Are you cold?” is sometimes useful, though it can sound like the beginning of a defense. “Would you like me to turn up the heat?” is better, provided it is not delivered in the tone of a man offering to surrender his only horse.
“Is it cold in here?” is the most dangerous question of all. It asks for an objective ruling from two witnesses whose hands are giving contradictory testimony.
The thermostat occupies a prominent position in our hallway, as if the house expected it to be consulted by everyone passing through. It glows faintly, displays a number, and accepts changes with a small, confident response. It has never once explained itself.
I approach the thermostat when the room feels warm. My wife approaches it when the room feels cool. We both believe we are responding to the room, not creating a problem for the other person.
My preferred number is the temperature at which I can move through the house without becoming aware of my own forehead. Her preferred number is the temperature at which she can sit through a movie without tucking her hands into her sleeves. Between those two numbers lies the region we call the compromise, though we visit it more often than we remain there.
I have tried explaining that the thermostat should not be treated like a faucet: turning it farther does not necessarily make the desired temperature arrive with greater enthusiasm. My wife has listened politely and then asked whether I might also stop turning it down before bed and expressing surprise when the house is cold in the morning.
This is a fair question. My nighttime self and my morning self have different priorities, and I have not always made introductions between them.
She has her own complicated relationship with the device. If she is chilled, she sometimes raises the setting, then forgets about it once she warms up. Hours later, I walk through the hallway and encounter a number that suggests someone has been trying to grow tomatoes in the coat closet.
I lower it. This feels less like changing her setting than restoring order. When she later raises it, she regards her action in much the same way.
We do not generally announce these adjustments. That makes them sound clandestine, but most of the time they are simply small acts performed while passing through the hall. The secrecy enters afterward, when one of us notices.
“Did you change the thermostat?”
“Yes. It was warm.”
“It’s still warm.”
“Exactly. Imagine how warm it was before.”
She does not accept my estimate because she was there before, wearing a sweater.
Sometimes we both stand in front of the thermostat, staring at the number as though it might provide an impartial account. It cannot tell us that she has been sitting near a draft or that I have just carried a basket upstairs. It does not know whether the sun was coming through the window ten minutes ago. It certainly does not know that she has been waiting all day to sit down, or that I have been looking forward to taking off my shoes.
It gives us a number, which is useful, and then leaves the rest to diplomacy.
Early in our marriage,…