Read a sample: 1. The Climate Agreement
The thermostat in our hallway is mounted at a height that suggests it was intended for adults. This is optimistic. The moment either of us approaches it, the other develops the watchfulness of a child who has just seen someone reach for the last cookie.
I noticed this one evening when I got up from the couch, walked down the hall, and touched the control.
“What are you doing?” my wife called.
The thermostat was around the corner from the living room. She could not see me.
“Looking at it.”
A pause.
“With your finger?”
I had indeed put my finger on it, but only because the display was dim. My intention, at that precise moment, was to learn the temperature. Whatever I might have done with that information was still a private matter.
She came into the hall carrying a blanket around her shoulders. I considered this an unnecessarily persuasive visual aid.
“What does it say?” she asked.
I told her.
“That’s comfortable.”
“It’s a number.”
“Yes,” she said. “A comfortable number.”
This is the foundation of the dispute. We agree that a home should be comfortable. We disagree about whether comfort is a condition of the air or a personal achievement involving additional layers.
My wife likes to sit down in the evening and remain aware of her hands. I like to sit down without feeling that the room has been preheated for a casserole. Both positions are reasonable, and neither of us has ever been improved by hearing the other say so.
We have discussed the matter during winter, summer, and the brief stretches between them when the weather changes its mind every six hours. The details vary with the season. In winter, the question is how much heat the house needs. In summer, it is how enthusiastically the air-conditioning should be encouraged. Throughout the year, a finger moving toward the thermostat can be interpreted as an announcement that one person’s comfort is more important than the other’s.
That is a lot of meaning to assign to a small rectangle in the hallway. It has a screen and two arrows. Somehow, we have made it into a referendum.
Our first apartment had a thermostat in the living room and a couch positioned so that both occupants could see it. This arrangement offered transparency, though not peace. We could observe each adjustment as it happened, along with the expression of the person making it.
A casual change was nearly impossible. You had to stand up, cross the room, face the wall, and operate a device while your spouse watched from approximately six feet away. The walk back to the couch was worse. You could pretend to be interested in a magazine, but the magazine would be upside down and your spouse would be asking whether you had changed something.
In our current house, the thermostat is in the hall. Privacy has introduced new difficulties.
For instance, a person might leave the living room to get a glass of water. On the way back, that person might glance at the display, find it unsuitable, and make a small correction. Ten minutes later, the other person might say, “Did it just get warmer in here?”
The first person then has several options, most of them poor.
“Yes” is honest, but it may prompt a discussion.
“I don’t know” is unwise if the first person is still holding the glass of water that established the opportunity.
“It was only one degree” shifts the conversation from the action to its size, which is useful only if the other person agrees that one degree is small. In our house, one degree can be negligible when I am requesting it and a major development when my wife has already made it.
The trouble is that touching the control can mean several things. It can mean, “I am uncomfortable.” It can mean, “The house feels different than it did an hour ago.” It can mean, “I thought you were asleep and would not notice.” Those are not equivalent messages, although they can look identical from the couch.
My wife once adjusted the thermostat while I was doing the dishes. She mentioned it as soon as I came into the hall.
“I turned it up,” she said. “My feet are freezing.”
“Okay,” I said, because she had told me, and because she had feet.
Half an hour later, I walked past the thermostat and turned it down. I did not mention this because, in my judgment, I was returning the house to its previous setting rather than making a new decision.
She discovered the change and asked why I had done it.
“I thought we were just trying it higher for a little while.”
“What made you think that?”
“You said your feet were freezing.”
“They still are.”
I had treated her explanation as a temporary weather report. She had offered it as evidence. We stood there long enough for me to recognize the distinction, though not long enough for her feet to warm up.
The obvious question, at least to me, was why she did not put on socks.
This question has a history. It has been asked gently, cheerfully, and once in a tone that caused me to begin apologizing before she answered.
My wife owns socks. She owns thick socks, soft socks, socks that stop at the ankle, and a pair with a…