Read a sample: 1. The Chat Is Born
The trouble began with a reasonable idea, which is how most family trouble likes to dress.
These fictionalized composite sketches follow an extended family with several branches, where the same first names turn up in more than one household and more than one person answers to Ben. The households have overlapping chats; June’s seventieth-birthday lunch is the appointment running through them. Other dinners and birthdays do not replace it, however much practice they give everyone.
Nora wanted to take her mother, June, out for her seventieth birthday. Nothing elaborate. Lunch somewhere pleasant, a cake if the restaurant allowed it, and enough people around the table that June could tell the story about the runaway wedding chicken to an audience that had not all heard it in the same room.
Nora mentioned this to her brother Eli on a Tuesday morning.
“Just immediate family,” she said.
“Perfect,” Eli said.
Neither of them asked what the other meant.
Nora created the group chat that afternoon while standing in her kitchen, waiting for the kettle to boil. She added Eli, their sister Tess, and June. Then she added their father, Martin, and their uncle Paul, June’s brother.
Six people, including Nora. Five additions.
The app asked her to name the conversation. She looked at the little row of faces and initials and typed The First Five.
Nora knew there were six people in the chat. She had counted them twice because she had once sent an invitation to a cousin’s old number and received a polite response from a stranger who was available but uncertain about the dress code. The First Five referred to the five people she had added, not the total membership.
This distinction was clear in her head and nowhere else.
Nora: Mom’s birthday lunch! Thinking we keep it simple and do immediate family. Is the second Saturday next month good?
Eli: Yes.
Tess: Yes to the date or yes to keeping it simple?
Eli: Both.
Martin: What time?
Nora: Haven’t got that far yet, Dad.
Martin: All right. Morning is difficult for me.
June: Why is it called The First Five?
Nora: I added five people.
Paul: There are six of us.
Nora: Including me.
Paul: You’re the first one, though, aren’t you?
Nora considered explaining that she was the creator rather than an addition, but the kettle had boiled and her tea was becoming a task.
Nora: It’s not an official title.
Tess: It sounds official. Like we’re the first five people evacuated from something.
Eli: Or a singing group.
June: I would like to be in the singing group.
Martin: I can’t sing in the morning.
This was the family’s first conversation in the new chat, and it established several useful principles. Nora would propose things. Eli would answer the question he believed had been asked. Tess would examine the question for structural weaknesses. Martin would provide a practical detail, often before anyone was ready for it. Paul would count. June would look for the part of the proceedings she could enjoy.
The principles were not written down. The family would nevertheless observe them faithfully.
Nora changed the name to June’s Birthday Lunch.
June: Much better.
Paul: Technically it was always your birthday lunch.
June: Yes, Paul, but now it sounds less like I’m being rescued from a tunnel.
For several minutes the plan appeared to be working. Nora sent the name of a restaurant with a long table in the back. June said she had eaten there once and remembered that the chairs were comfortable. Martin wanted to know whether there was parking. Eli said he would call about the table.
Then Tess asked whether she should bring Ben.
Ben was Tess’s husband. He had been married to her for eleven years, knew where June kept the spare batteries, and had once spent an entire holiday afternoon fixing Martin’s printer while Martin stood beside him saying, “It didn’t use to do that.”
Nora: Of course bring Ben.
Tess: I thought so. You said immediate family.
Nora: He is immediate family.
Eli: Does that mean Priya too?
Priya was Eli’s partner. She had been in the family for four years, although the family disagreed cheerfully about the exact date of her arrival. Eli counted from their first date. June counted from the first time Priya came for dinner. Martin counted from the day she showed him how to make the printer stop producing a blank page after every document.
Nora: Yes, Priya too.
June: And Owen, obviously.
Owen was Nora’s adult son. He lived across town, worked weekends sometimes, and had recently begun saying “Let me check my calendar” in a tone that made him sound like a small, exhausted dentist.
Nora: Yes, Owen. I’ll ask him.
Eli: I can see why you started a chat.
At this point there were nine people in the lunch party: Nora, Eli, Tess, June, Martin, Paul, Ben, Priya, and Owen. Six were in the chat. Ben, Priya, and Owen had not been added, but Nora wrote their names on a list beside the kettle.
The list looked reassuring. Lists often do, before the people on them begin to speak.
Nora: So that’s nine. I’ll see if the restaurant can take us.
Paul: What about Clara?
Clara was Paul’s wife. She had missed the last two family gatherings because one had fallen during a work trip and the other had coincided…