Read a sample: 1. The List
By the time Nora arrived at her birthday dinner, Jules had already persuaded the waiter to move them away from a table beneath a speaker, even though neither of them had yet sat at it.
“It was playing a cover of a song I like,” Jules explained, standing to hug her. “I didn’t want that happening to us all evening.”
Nora held on a moment longer than usual. Jules smelled like rain and the hand cream she kept buying in optimistic scents: grapefruit, coastal linen, something once described as productive morning.
“Happy birthday,” Jules said into her hair. “You’re damp.”
“It’s raining.”
“I know. I’m also damp, but I got here first, so I’m allowed to comment.”
The restaurant was the kind of place that put candles in small jars and called its fries something more ambitious than fries. Nora had chosen it because she liked the food and because the tables were close enough together to make eavesdropping possible without requiring a commitment. At the next one, a man was describing his new mattress with the careful authority of someone who had spent an entire weekend reading about foam.
Nora slipped into her chair and put her bag on the floor. Jules had brought a gift in a paper bag with a crooked tissue-paper arrangement sticking out of the top.
“You said no presents,” Jules said.
“I did.”
“But you say that every year, and one year I believed you, and your face—”
“My face was perfectly gracious.”
“Your mouth was gracious. Your eyebrows called my mother.”
Nora smiled and reached for the bag. Under the tissue was a small blue notebook with a soft cover, the sort that made an unwritten list seem like a promising life choice.
“For the things you don’t want to forget,” Jules said.
Nora turned it over in her hands. “This is lovely.”
“And for the things you do want to forget, but insist on writing down anyway. Like what the plumber said.”
“The plumber was vague.”
“The plumber said the pipe was old.”
“He wouldn’t tell me how old.”
“I think he meant ‘old’ as a pipe condition, not a request to see its birth certificate.”
Nora opened the notebook. Jules had written Nora’s Extremely Reasonable Concerns on the first page and drawn a tiny border of alarm bells around it.
“It’s beautiful,” Nora said. “I hate you.”
“I know.”
They had been friends since the first week of high school, when Jules had borrowed a pen and returned it three days later with a cap from an entirely different pen. Nora had pointed this out. Jules had said she thought the replacement gave it character. For reasons neither could now fully explain, they had eaten lunch together afterward, and then for years.
A waiter appeared to take their drink order. Jules asked for sparkling water with lime. Nora, who had spent the taxi ride rehearsing a casual way to order the same thing, looked up too quickly.
“Just water for me,” she said.
Jules glanced at her. “Not even a birthday cocktail?”
“I had a headache earlier.”
This was not entirely untrue. Nora had briefly had a headache on Tuesday, and she had enjoyed the simplicity of it: a discomfort with an obvious name and a reliable ending.
“Then still water for us both,” Jules said. “The sparkling can be very aggressive.”
When the waiter left, Nora said, “You don’t have to give up bubbles because I have a headache.”
“I’m not. I forgot the lime here always tastes like it’s been cut with a knife that previously handled an onion.”
“You’ve thought about this.”
“I’ve had several months since we last came.”
Nora placed the notebook beside her menu. She had planned to tell Jules over dinner. Specifically, she had planned to tell her after they ordered but before the food came, giving Jules enough time to react and both of them enough time to discuss it before a waiter arrived with anything balanced on his arm.
The plan had seemed practical until she saw Jules across the restaurant. Then the news, which had belonged to Nora and her husband, Ben, for several weeks, suddenly felt too large to fit between the bread plate and the candle.
Jules studied the menu. “I remember liking the mushroom thing.”
“The risotto?”
“Possibly. It may have been more of a toast.”
“Those are different things.”
“I remember the mushroom part clearly.”
They ordered the risotto and the toast to share, settling the question in the only way Jules considered intellectually honest.
“So,” Jules said when the menus had gone, “how is Ben’s campaign against the wardrobe?”
“It won.”
“He couldn’t fix the door?”
“He fixed it so well we can’t open it.”
Jules laughed. “That’s an advanced repair.”
“He says the hinge needs adjusting.”
“Can you get to the hinge?”
“It’s inside.”
“Has he considered living without clothes?”
“He’s considered getting a professional. I’m trying not to show too much excitement in case he changes his mind.”
Ben had been behaving with such attentive sweetness lately that Nora felt a little disloyal making fun of his carpentry. This morning he had left a packet of crackers on her bedside table and a note that said For your highly demanding roommate. She had cried over the note, then cried because she was crying over a note about crackers.
She wanted to tell Jules that…