Read a sample: 1. A Simple Dinner
The first problem with planning a surprise dinner for Nina was that Nina generally knew where everyone was.
Not in a sinister way. She simply paid attention. If Jo mentioned a dentist appointment on Tuesday, Nina would ask on Wednesday how it had gone. If Tess bought shoes for a wedding three months away, Nina remembered both the wedding and the shoes, even after Tess returned them. When Mara had once claimed to be “just around the corner,” Nina had said, “You’re still at home, aren’t you?” and Mara had looked down at her slippers.
“She does that because she loves us,” Mara said.
“She does it because you pause before you lie,” Jo said.
They were sitting at Mara’s kitchen table on a Sunday afternoon, surrounded by the remains of lunch. Mara had made a salad large enough to suggest the arrival of additional guests, and Jo had brought a loaf of bread that was now represented by crumbs and a small heel nobody wanted to claim.
Mara stacked their plates. “I don’t pause.”
Jo looked at her.
“I pause thoughtfully,” Mara said.
“Much better.”
Nina’s birthday was in a few weeks, and the previous evening she had mentioned it in the way she mentioned most things she didn’t want to make a fuss about: briefly, while asking someone else a question.
“Apparently I have a birthday coming up,” she’d said, passing Mara a bowl of olives. “Do you want the last one?”
Mara had wanted the last one. She had also noticed that Nina had no plans beyond taking the day off work and deciding later what to do with it.
Nina often decided later. Other people’s occasions had a way of filling the space first. She made reservations, remembered allergies, brought the card around for signatures, and somehow knew which bakery could write a name on a cake without making it look like a threat. When her own birthday arrived, she tended to say she was happy with anything, and everyone believed her because Nina was good at being happy with whatever was in front of her.
Mara thought she deserved a night when somebody else handled the details.
“Just dinner,” she said now. “A surprise. The four of us and Nina. Somewhere nice.”
Jo picked a sesame seed from the table. “That sounds manageable.”
“Exactly.”
This was the point at which they should perhaps have stopped talking. They could have carried the lovely, untested idea into the afternoon like a covered dish, intact and still warm. Instead, Jo asked what Mara meant by nice.
“You know,” Mara said.
“I don’t.”
“Good food. A table. Pleasant lighting.”
“Those are three things.”
“They’re compatible things.”
Jo considered. She was a practical woman with a talent for finding the question everyone else had walked past on their way to enthusiasm. She could make a packing list for a weekend away that accounted for rain, blisters, and a sudden change of heart about swimming. She had also once attended a picnic with an actual knife for cutting cheese, which Mara regarded as evidence of either exceptional foresight or a secret second life.
“Does it have to be a surprise?” Jo asked.
“I think she’d like one.”
“Would she like being surprised in a restaurant?”
“She likes restaurants.”
“She likes knowing whether she needs to wash her hair.”
Mara thought about this. “We can make sure she’s going out.”
“How?”
“I haven’t worked out every detail.”
Jo smiled. “Good. I was worried you’d already made a folder.”
“I haven’t.”
“Is there a folder in your head?”
“There’s an area.”
Jo laughed, and Mara took the plates to the sink before the area could be discussed further.
The thing was, Mara enjoyed arranging things. She liked the moment a plan stopped being a possibility and became a real place at a real time, with a reservation under someone’s name. She liked knowing that the cake would arrive after the main course and that nobody had been left standing outside in the rain because the address was missing a digit.
She did not, as Tess had once suggested, enjoy controlling the movements of other adults. She merely preferred those movements to result in everyone getting dinner.
“Tess and Priya should help,” Mara said, rinsing a fork.
“They should definitely be invited.”
“I mean help plan it.”
Jo leaned back in her chair. “All right.”
Mara turned. “You said that in a way.”
“I said two words.”
“The second one was cautious.”
“I’m picturing Tess suggesting a restaurant where the chairs are made of sculpture.”
“Chairs can be sculpture.”
“Yes. That’s what worries me.”
Mara dried her hands. “Tess knows places. Priya will think of things we miss. You’ll keep us sensible.”
“And you?”
“I’ll keep us moving.”
Jo gave her a look that was fond enough to be allowed.
Mara picked up her phone, then put it down again. “We shouldn’t start discussing it in the usual chat.”
“That would be my advice, yes.”
“I know that. I’m saying it out loud so we remember.”
“Excellent. We’re off to a discreet start.”
They decided to call Tess and Priya individually. Mara had suggested a group call, but Jo pointed out that Tess was at a birthday brunch and Priya had said she was spending the afternoon with her parents. A surprise for Nina did not require interrupting two other people’s Sundays at the…