Read a sample: 1. The Appointment Was Yesterday
On Thursday morning, Margaret Hale arrived at the clinic eight minutes early, carrying her insurance card, a list of medications, and a cardigan in case the building had been designed by people who stored fish.
She approached the reception desk with the agreeable confidence of a woman who had found a parking space on the first pass.
“Margaret Hale,” she said. “Eleven o’clock with Dr. Patel.”
The receptionist consulted her screen. She had a silver ring on each hand and the calm expression of someone who spent her working hours delivering information that was unlikely to improve anybody’s day.
“Your appointment was yesterday.”
Margaret smiled. “I don’t think it was.”
The receptionist turned the monitor slightly, though not far enough for Margaret to read it. “Wednesday at eleven.”
Margaret considered this. “I have it down for Thursday.”
“I’m sorry. It was Wednesday.”
There were several possible responses. Margaret selected the one that required the least immediate paperwork.
“Is there any chance Dr. Patel could see me today?”
The receptionist checked. “Not today, I’m afraid. I can offer you next Tuesday at two-fifteen.”
Margaret had a volunteer shift Tuesday morning and was meeting a contractor at four. Two-fifteen left enough room between them, provided the contractor continued his long-standing practice of arriving after four.
“I’ll take it.”
The receptionist printed a card. Margaret read it before putting it in her bag.
“Tuesday,” she said. “Two-fifteen.”
“That’s right.”
“I’m going to write it down while we both watch.”
She took a small notebook from her bag and entered the appointment. The receptionist watched with professional interest, as if Margaret had announced a brief demonstration.
“There,” Margaret said. “Now, if I’m wrong next week, we’ll have a witness.”
The receptionist smiled. “Would you like a reminder call?”
“Yes, please.”
Outside, Margaret stood beside her car and reviewed the morning. She was not upset with the receptionist, who had been courteous and had found her another appointment. She was not especially upset with herself, either, because the question of herself had not yet been settled.
She was, however, interested.
Margaret’s calendar hung on the kitchen wall beside the refrigerator. It had large squares, clear numbers, and photographs of gardens that had never been asked to accommodate a hose, a dog, or a municipal water restriction. Every appointment went on it in blue ink. Birthdays went in green. Anything that involved another person coming to the house went in red, partly so Margaret would remember to be there and partly so she would remember to move the shoes away from the door.
At home, she put the appointment card on the counter and opened the calendar.
There it was: Dr. Patel, 11:00, written in blue in Thursday’s square.
Wednesday contained two items: library books and call Jean re: Saturday. Both had been crossed out. Margaret had returned the books and called Jean, who was hosting a gathering in her garden and had asked whether Margaret could bring folding chairs.
Margaret stared at the neat blue entry. Her handwriting did not look uncertain. It looked like the handwriting of a person who had been given a date and had written it in the appropriate square.
She took the card from the counter and entered the new appointment on Tuesday.
Then she drew a small circle around Thursday’s mistake. She did not cross it out. Crossing it out suggested a task had been completed, and she disliked giving the calendar credit it had not earned.
The telephone rang.
“Did you get your knees done?” Jean asked.
“My knees are still attached, if that’s what you mean.”
“I meant the appointment.”
“I went today. Apparently it was yesterday.”
“Oh.”
“I’m conducting an inquiry.”
“Good. Because yesterday I thought you said you had it today.”
“I did say that.”
“Well, that supports your case.”
“It supports the fact that I told you what was on my calendar.”
“Still,” Jean said, “I’m willing to testify.”
Margaret pulled out a chair. “Did I tell you that yesterday, or did I tell you earlier in the week?”
“Yesterday. You called about the chairs.”
“And I said the appointment was today?”
“You said you could drop the chairs off after your appointment tomorrow. I said there was no rush, because the party isn’t until Saturday.”
Margaret remembered the conversation. She had been standing at the sink, looking out at the bird feeder, while Jean described the location of every table she owned. Margaret had offered the folding chairs because Jean’s guest list had grown beyond the seating capacity of the original plan.
“Thank you,” Margaret said. “That establishes what I believed yesterday.”
“Which is often helpful to know.”
“It doesn’t establish why I believed it.”
“Was there a reminder?”
“Two, actually.”
“Then I’d start there.”
After hanging up, Margaret took her phone from her bag. She had two voicemail messages from the clinic. She had saved them because both had arrived when she was doing something else, and she had intended to delete them later. This was an untidy habit, but it had suddenly become an evidence-preservation strategy.
The first message had arrived Monday afternoon.
“Hello, this is a reminder from Willow Lane Clinic that Margaret Hale has an appointment with Dr. Patel on Wednesday at eleven a.m. Please call our office if you need to reschedule.”
Margaret played it again.
“Wednesday,” she said aloud.
She looked at the calendar. Thursday continued to…