Read a sample: 1. The List Is a Suggestion
The list was on the refrigerator, held in place by a magnet shaped like a lobster. It had six items, each written on its own line in my husband’s careful block letters.
Chicken. Onions. Tomatoes. Eggs. Milk. Bread.
Underneath, Ben had drawn a small box for each item. This was unnecessary, because he also crossed things out. I had asked him once why he needed both systems, and he had said, “The box tells me I found it. The line tells me we’re done.”
We had been married long enough for me to understand that these were different events.
“We only need six things?” I asked.
“For dinner tonight and breakfast tomorrow.” He stood beside me, holding his car keys. “I checked.”
I opened the refrigerator. There was half a lemon, a jar of pickles, a container of rice, two kinds of mustard, and a small bowl covered with a plate.
“What’s in the bowl?” he asked.
“If I knew, I wouldn’t have covered it.”
Ben leaned in. “That sounds like evidence.”
“It’s probably evidence of lunch.”
He lifted the plate. Inside was one cooked sausage, cut into three pieces.
We looked at it.
“That could go in the rice,” I said.
“It could. But let’s still get the six things.”
I was agreeable. I am often agreeable before we enter a grocery store.
My name is Liza, and I like a plan. I also like seeing what happens to the plan when eggplants are beautiful, bread is fresh, or somebody puts the good crackers near the cheese. Ben believes a list should protect us from these discoveries. I believe a list should be sturdy enough to survive them.
At the store, he reached for a handbasket.
I took a cart.
He looked at the cart. “Six things.”
“And a sausage.”
“The sausage is at home.”
“Yes. We know where one thing is already. We’re doing great.”
He gave me the basket to put back.
The cart made a soft clicking sound as we rolled through the entrance. Ben took out the list, glanced at it, and then looked up at the overhead signs.
“Produce first,” he said. “Then meat, dairy, and bread on the way out. We can be done in fifteen minutes.”
“You timed it?”
“I estimated.”
“With a watch?”
“With experience.”
“Your experience or our experience?”
He folded the list in half. “Let’s not lose our first three minutes discussing minutes.”
The tomatoes were beside a display of mangoes. I picked up a tomato, turned it over, and set it in a bag. Ben chose an onion with the concentration of a man selecting a witness.
“These look good,” I said, holding up a mango.
“We’re here for tomatoes.”
“I know. They’re right next to the mangoes.”
He considered the mango. “Do we have a plan for it?”
“We could eat it.”
“When?”
“When it’s ready.”
He gave me a patient look. Ben has several patient looks, and I am familiar with all of them. This one meant he thought I was being charming on purpose, which I was, but I also wanted the mango.
I put two in the cart.
“Two?” he said.
“So neither of us has to watch the other one eat.”
“I can handle watching you eat a mango.”
“That’s sweet. You don’t have to.”
He put the onion in the cart and checked its box. Then he checked the box for tomatoes. Neither word received a line through it.
“Not done?” I asked.
“We’re still in produce.”
There was logic to that, though I suspected he had made it up just now.
At the mushrooms, Ben stopped. He picked up a package, checked the price, and put it in the cart.
I waited.
“What?” he said.
“Are mushrooms on the list?”
“They’ll be good with the chicken.”
“So you have a plan.”
“Yes.”
“Then I support your mangoes.”
He glanced back toward the fruit. “Those were your mangoes.”
“We’re married. Your mushrooms are my mushrooms.”
“That seems like an arrangement I should have read more carefully.”
We moved on to the greens. I wanted bok choy; Ben wanted the kind of lettuce that came washed in a box. Both seemed sensible, so naturally we discussed them as though only one could be chosen.
“The bok choy can go with dinner,” I said.
“The lettuce can go with dinner.”
“The lettuce can also wait until tomorrow.”
“So can the bok choy.”
I looked at him. “Why are we arguing?”
“I thought you were.”
“I was explaining.”
“So was I.”
We put both in the cart, which felt like the conclusion of a productive meeting, although neither of us could say what had been resolved.
Near the chicken, a sign announced a sale on family packs. Ben picked one up and held it out for inspection.
“That’s a lot of chicken,” I said.
“We can freeze half.”
I looked at him with the same patience he had used on my mangoes.
“What?” he said.
“Do we have a plan for it?”
“Yes. We freeze half.”
“That’s a location. I’m asking about a plan.”
“We eat it later.”
“When?”
“When it’s ready.”
He smiled before he could stop himself. “Fine. Get the smaller one.”
I compared the packages. The larger one did look like a good deal, and we were going to need dinner again after tonight, a fact I could generally count on. I…