Read a sample: 1. When Breathing Becomes Awkward
Someone says, “Just notice your breath,” and suddenly breathing is all you can think about.
A moment ago, it was happening on its own. Now you wonder whether you are doing it correctly. Should the next breath be deeper? Is it supposed to be quieter? Are you breathing too quickly? The more carefully you pay attention, the less natural the whole thing seems.
Or perhaps the awkwardness arrives differently. You feel bored almost immediately. You notice a tightness you would rather not examine. You become impatient with the instruction to sit still. Maybe you simply dislike being told to focus on something so close and personal.
If any of this sounds familiar, you are not alone in finding breath awareness complicated. An instruction that seems simple can bring a surprising amount of effort with it. You may have come to mindfulness hoping for a little more ease, only to find yourself monitoring an ordinary bodily function and wondering when it became a task.
This book begins with a different possibility: you do not have to make yourself comfortable with breath awareness before you can explore mindfulness. You can be curious about what happens when you notice breathing, and you can also choose to pay attention elsewhere. The feeling of your feet against the floor, the weight of your body on a chair, the sight of a familiar object, or a sound in the room can be just as suitable a place to begin.
There is no test to pass here. Your reactions are information, not evidence that you are unsuited to practice.
Breathing is unusual because it generally continues without conscious direction, yet we can also influence it. We can hold our breath briefly, sigh, speak, sing, or choose to take a larger breath. That flexibility is useful in daily life, but it can make the instruction to “notice your breathing” feel puzzling.
What does noticing mean when the thing you are noticing can change as soon as you attend to it?
You might begin by observing a breath and then find yourself helping it along. Perhaps you wait for an inhale, guide the exhale, or try to make each breath match the one before it. Once you notice that you are managing the breath, you may try to stop managing it—which can feel like another form of management.
There is nothing strange about getting caught in that loop. Attention can make a familiar process feel unfamiliar. The same thing can happen if you think too hard about how you walk down stairs or where your tongue rests when your mouth is closed. You have not forgotten how to do these things. You have simply become aware of details that usually remain in the background.
When this happens with breathing, it may help to release the idea that you must find a perfectly natural breath and keep it there. A breath that changes while you notice it is not a failed breath. Nor do you need to solve the question of how much influence you are having. If the whole experience becomes tiresome, you can let the question rest and turn your attention toward something else.
For now, you might look at an object nearby. Notice its color or outline, if that is comfortable. There is no need to hold your gaze perfectly steady or to make your breathing behave while you look. The object is simply something else available to notice.
Many mindfulness instructions use the breath because it is readily available and changes from moment to moment. But readily available does not always mean pleasant to observe. What is accessible to one person may feel intrusive to another.
You might notice a tendency to supervise your breathing rather than observe it. An inhale feels too shallow, so you add a little more. An exhale seems too short, so you stretch it. Then you wonder whether you have interfered too much and attempt to return to whatever was happening before.
It can be difficult to step back from this kind of supervision by trying harder. Effort may be the very thing that has made the exercise feel crowded.
Consider what happens when you listen to a person speaking. You do not need to anticipate every word or make the conversation unfold at a particular speed. At the same time, you are free to look away, shift in your seat, or decide that you have listened enough. Attention can be receptive rather than controlling, and it can move.
Breath awareness can be approached in that spirit, but it is not necessary to insist on it. If listening to breathing feels like supervising it, an outward focus may give your attention somewhere less demanding to go. You could notice the shape of a doorway, the texture of a sleeve, or the contact between your back and a supporting surface. You do not have to stop being aware of your breath first. It can be present in the background, even if it still feels a little awkward.
Sometimes the awkwardness fades when attention moves. Sometimes it remains noticeable for a while. Neither response tells you whether you are practicing correctly. You are learning what happens for you, not trying to produce a particular result.
Perhaps you came to a breathing exercise because you wanted relief from a busy day. Then, instead of feeling calmer, you became more aware of restlessness, tension, or…