Everyday Guidebooks
Cover of The Self Publishing Guide to Editorial Decisions

More Books

The Self Publishing Guide to Editorial Decisions

How to Choose Editing Services, Compare Quotes, Budget Wisely, and Work With an Editor

by Todd Michael

Available now

Your manuscript is finished—or is it ready for an editor? Knowing which kind of help to hire can be as challenging as writing the book itself.

The Self Publishing Guide to Editorial Decisions is a self publishing guide book for independent authors who want to spend their editing budget with purpose. Todd Michael explains what developmental editing, copyediting, and proofreading actually do, how their boundaries can vary, and why the order of work matters.

Learn to assess your manuscript, identify the questions to ask a prospective editor, and compare sample edits without mistaking a heavy hand for a better result. Use practical frameworks for requesting quotes, weighing price against scope and fit, planning a budget, and reviewing agreements before work begins. Once feedback arrives, you'll learn how to sort suggestions, make revisions, and resolve disagreements while retaining ownership of your book.

Make your next editorial decision with clarity—not guesswork.

Contents
  1. 1. Editorial Decisions Begin With Your Book
  2. 2. What Developmental Editing Does
  3. The Big-Picture View
  4. Developmental Editing for Fiction
  5. Developmental Editing for Nonfiction
  6. Reader Expectations and Authorial Choice
  7. What a Full Developmental Edit May Include
  8. Developmental Edit or Editorial Assessment?
  9. Recognizing a Developmental Issue
  10. Before You Commission the Work
  11. 3. What Copyediting Does
  12. 4. What Proofreading Does
  13. 5. Assess Your Manuscript Before You Shop
  14. 6. Choose a Sequence of Services
  15. 7. Set an Editing Budget
  16. 8. Find and Shortlist Editors
  17. 9. Request Quotes That Can Be Compared
  18. 10. Evaluate Sample Edits
  19. 11. Compare Proposals and Choose
  20. 12. Agree on the Work
  21. 13. Work Through Editorial Feedback
  22. 14. Close the Editorial Loop
  23. Other Books by Todd Michael

Read a sample: 1. Editorial Decisions Begin With Your Book

The first editorial decision is not which editor to hire. It is what you are trying to make.

You may have a complete manuscript, a publication date in mind, and a folder of recommendations from other authors. You may also have a persistent suspicion that something is not working, even if you cannot yet name it. Before you request a quote or compare editing packages, pause long enough to describe the book, its readers, and the condition of the draft.

That pause is practical, not ceremonial. An editor can offer more useful advice when you can explain what you want the book to accomplish and where you feel uncertain. You can compare proposals more confidently when you know whether you need help with the book’s structure, the clarity of its sentences, or the accuracy of its final pages. You can also protect your budget by avoiding work that may have to be repeated after a major revision.

You do not need to diagnose every problem on your own. If you could see every weakness clearly, you might not need outside help. Your responsibility is to provide an honest starting point: what the book is, whom it is for, how far the manuscript has progressed, and what resources you can commit.

The chapters ahead will help you investigate the available services and make specific choices. For now, the goal is to understand the route from draft to publication and establish a foundation for those choices.

As an independent author, you are the decision-maker for your book. You may hire experienced professionals, but you remain responsible for the final manuscript and the choices surrounding it.

That responsibility does not mean you must know how to perform every task yourself. A publisher can rely on designers, editors, proofreaders, and other specialists without being one of them. As the author-publisher, you can do the same. Your job is to identify the help you need, communicate your goals, evaluate the advice you receive, and decide what enters the published book.

An editor brings a trained outside perspective. Depending on the assignment, that perspective might reveal a weak argument, an unconvincing character motivation, a pattern of confusing sentences, or inconsistencies in spelling and terminology. An editor can explain concerns and suggest solutions, but the scope of the work depends on your agreement. Hiring someone to improve a manuscript is not the same as transferring ownership of every decision.

Consider a nonfiction author whose draft contains a chapter that repeats material from earlier in the book. A developmental editor might recommend cutting or reorganizing it. The author can accept that recommendation, retain the chapter for a deliberate reason, or find another solution that addresses the underlying concern. If the chapter stays unchanged, the repetition may stay, too. The choice belongs to the author, along with its consequences for the reader.

The same principle applies to fiction. An editor might question the ending of a mystery because the solution depends on information the reader could not reasonably have noticed. The author need not adopt the editor’s proposed ending. But dismissing the concern without considering the reader’s experience would leave a potentially important problem unresolved.

Think of editorial work as informed collaboration rather than approval or correction imposed from outside. You bring the book’s purpose, subject knowledge, creative intentions, and authority over the final text. The editor brings an independent reading and skills suited to an agreed task. The strongest working relationship gives each contribution room.

Every manuscript follows its own path. Some authors revise extensively before seeking professional help; others seek an early assessment because they are unsure how to proceed. Not every book needs every service, and some stages overlap. Even so, a general map can help you understand why the order of decisions matters.

Most projects move through some version of these stages:

1. Draft and revise. You create a complete manuscript and revise it using your own judgment and, where useful, feedback from trusted readers. 2. Address larger concerns. You examine whether the book’s structure, content, and approach serve its intended readers. Outside help at this stage might take the form of an editorial assessment or developmental editing. 3. Refine the text. Once substantial changes are largely complete, copyediting can address matters such as clarity, consistency, grammar, and style within an agreed scope. 4. Prepare the book for publication. You review editorial changes, resolve questions, and arrange the text in its intended publication format. 5. Check the near-final version. Proofreading can identify remaining errors and presentation problems in a manuscript or formatted proof, depending on the assignment. 6. Approve and publish. You review the final files, make publication decisions, and authorize the version readers will receive.

This map is not a mandatory shopping list. It is a way to see the relationship between tasks. A writer with a strong, well-tested manuscript may make different choices from a writer who has finished a first draft and suspects the book needs substantial reorganization. A constrained budget may require priorities rather than a full sequence of paid services.

The order matters because changes at one stage affect work done at another. If an editor polishes a chapter’s sentences and you later remove half the chapter, some of that work no longer benefits the finished book. If you add several pages after proofreading, the new material has not received the same check as the rest. Neither situation is a…

More More Books

Cover of Dog Breeds for Real LifeDog Breeds for Real LifeAvailable nowCover of How to Find the Right Dog Breed for Your HouseholdHow to Find the Right Dog Breed for Your HouseholdAvailable nowCover of Digital Nomad Ideas for Accessible Remote WorkDigital Nomad Ideas for Accessible Remote WorkAvailable nowCover of The Bathhouse Keeper's Day OffThe Bathhouse Keeper's Day OffAvailable nowCover of A Hurricane Guide for CaregiversA Hurricane Guide for CaregiversAvailable nowThe Fountain Pen FamiliarComing soon

About Todd Michael

Todd Michael is an American author and the founder of ToddMichael.tv. He writes practical, plain-English books on money, health, preparedness, technology, games, humor and more.

About the author Todd Michael · Todd Michael’s author site

Part of the ToddMichael.tv network.