Read a sample: 1. A Most Offensive Quotation
The first sign that Edwin Vale was upset was the book standing on its edge.
Lena Moss stopped in the doorway of the archive workroom, a paper bag of currant buns in one hand and her umbrella dripping onto the mat. Martin Bell’s newly published history of the town had been lying flat on her desk when she went out for lunch. Now it was balanced upright, its green cover trembling against the blotter.
Edwin hovered behind it, his expression severe enough to curdle the milk in Lena’s tea.
“You’ve learned a new trick,” she said.
“I have not. The book is leaning against the inkwell.”
“It was lying down.”
“Mrs. Partridge came in while you were out. She propped it up to admire the cover. I have been looking at it ever since.”
Lena set down the buns. “That does sound trying.”
“It is open to the wrong page.”
“An outrage.”
“Miss Moss.”
When Edwin used her surname, trouble was generally close behind. When he used her surname and folded his transparent arms, it had usually found a chair and made itself comfortable.
Lena closed the umbrella and put it in the stand. Outside the tall windows, rain blurred Moss Street into a wash of slate roofs and shopfronts. Across the road, the florist was bringing in her buckets, one at a time, while a determined customer inspected a bunch of dahlias beneath an awning.
“What page would you like?” Lena asked.
“One hundred and twelve.”
She laid the book flat and opened it. Moss Street and the Making of a Town had arrived that morning with a handwritten invitation to Martin’s launch on Friday evening. Lena had admired the cover, glanced at the index, and found herself listed once, in the acknowledgments, for helping him locate a photograph of the old tram stop. Edwin had apparently read further.
“Halfway down,” he said.
Lena followed his gaze. The paragraph concerned the strip of land now occupied by the town garden, behind the former railway offices. Martin described the property’s passage through several hands and its eventual use as a public garden. Then came the sentence that had evidently disturbed the peace of the archive.
“‘As town clerk Edwin Vale put it, “A garden for all is a garden for none, and the sooner the public is kept out, the better.”’”
She glanced up. “Did you?”
“No.”
“You sound certain.”
“I was there.”
“A useful qualification in a witness.”
“Not always, apparently.”
Edwin drifted nearer the desk. He looked as he always did: a narrow man in a dark waistcoat, with neat silver hair and the air of someone who had just discovered a mistake in a column of figures. The light from the window showed through his shoulder, though Lena had long ago stopped finding that remarkable. More remarkable was the fact that he had remained patient while she went out for buns.
“He might have misunderstood you,” she said.
“I fail to see how. I never said it, wrote it, or thought it. I was fond of that garden.”
“Was it a garden in your day?”
“Not as you know it. There were fruit trees along the wall and a patch of vegetables that the railway porter’s wife tended. She gave me a pear once.”
Lena waited.
“It was an excellent pear.”
“Then Martin has committed a grave injustice.”
“Thank you.”
“I haven’t decided whether I believe you yet.”
Edwin gave her a look of wounded dignity. “You have known me for nearly four years.”
“And in that time I’ve heard you object to public access, dogs, damp coats, ballpoint pens, children eating raisins near the registers, and the placement of my kettle.”
“The kettle was directly beneath a shelf of minutes.”
“It still is.”
“I continue to object.”
Lena tore open the paper bag and set a bun on a saucer. She would have offered Edwin one out of courtesy, but the gesture tended to make him gloomy. He could see and hear almost everything in the archive, and could make himself visible to Lena whenever he pleased, but food, doors, papers, and other useful objects remained beyond his reach. He had once spent an entire afternoon trying to turn a page by blowing on it. Lena had eventually turned it for him, after suggesting that the manuscript deserved a little peace.
He watched her break the bun apart.
“I did object to people trampling the vegetable beds,” he said. “That is rather different from wishing to keep the public out.”
“Perhaps the source will make the distinction clear.”
“That is precisely what I have been trying to tell you.”
He inclined his head toward the small number at the end of the sentence. Lena turned to the notes at the back.
“Chapter six,” she murmured. “Note twenty-seven.”
Martin’s citation read: “Edwin Vale to Arthur Penrose, 14 September 1891, Penrose family papers, Moss Street Archive, box 4, folder 12.”
Edwin stared at the page. “Arthur Penrose.”
“You knew him?”
“Of course. He owned the railway offices before the railway company did. He was also extraordinarily attached to his own opinions.”
“Was he attached to the garden?”
“He was attached to the idea of other people not having things he could have himself.”
“That sounds almost quotable.”
“I hope Mr. Bell will resist.”
Lena copied the citation onto a slip of paper, including the letter’s author, recipient, and…