Everyday Guidebooks
Cover of The Entrepreneur Idea Selection Guide

Business, AI & Entrepreneurship

The Entrepreneur Idea Selection Guide

A Practical Scoring Method for Comparing Business Ideas and Choosing What to Investigate Next

by Todd Michael

Available now

You have more than one business idea—and only so much time, money, and energy to pursue it. How do you decide where to start?

The Entrepreneur Idea Selection Guide gives you a practical way to compare possibilities before you commit to building a business. Instead of chasing the most exciting concept or searching for a perfect answer, you’ll assess each entrepreneur idea against four realities: your available resources, relevant experience, access to potential customers, and tolerance for risk.

Follow a step-by-step scoring method to set your criteria, examine assumptions, weigh tradeoffs, and challenge a tempting result. Worked examples show how different circumstances can lead to different choices, while reusable worksheets help you apply the process to your own ideas.

You won’t find a promise that any score predicts success. You’ll find a clearer, more defensible decision about which idea deserves your next round of investigation.

Contents
  1. 1. The Decision Before the Business
  2. 2. Build a Comparable Shortlist
  3. 3. Take Stock of Your Resources
  4. 4. Map Your Relevant Experience
  5. 5. Assess Access to Customers
  6. Start With the Customer in Your Idea Statement
  7. Inventory the Routes You Have
  8. Look at the Strength of Each Route
  9. A Separate Hypothetical Illustration
  10. Separate Reach, Response, and Purchase
  11. Account for Gatekeepers and Buying Context
  12. Consider the Cost of Building Access
  13. Create an Access Map for Each Idea
  14. Carry the Findings Forward
  15. 6. Define Your Risk Boundaries
  16. 7. Create Your Scoring Criteria
  17. 8. Give Each Idea an Initial Score
  18. 9. Weight What Matters Most
  19. 10. Make the Tradeoffs Visible
  20. Read the Profile, Not Just the Position
  21. Look at Maya’s Comparison
  22. Separate Weaknesses From Boundaries
  23. Scenario One: The Resource-Intensive Idea
  24. Scenario Two: The Familiar Idea
  25. Scenario Three: The Easily Reached Customer Group
  26. Notice Interactions Between Criteria
  27. Build a Short Tradeoff Record
  28. Carry the Right Question Forward
  29. 11. Challenge Your Favorite
  30. 12. Choose What to Investigate
  31. 13. Plan the Next Inquiry
  32. 14. Your Reusable Selection Toolkit
  33. The Blank Toolkit
  34. A Complete Worked Example
  35. When to Revisit the Decision
  36. Other Books by Todd Michael

Read a sample: 1. The Decision Before the Business

Having several business ideas can feel like an advantage until it is time to choose among them. One idea seems exciting, another makes use of skills you already have, and a third appears easier to start. Each becomes more appealing when you imagine its best outcome—and less appealing when you consider what it might require.

You may respond by collecting more ideas, reading about other founders, or sketching plans for several businesses at once. Those activities can be useful, but they can also postpone the decision in front of you. Your immediate task is not to choose the business that will define the rest of your working life. It is to decide which idea deserves your limited investigative time and resources first.

That distinction makes the decision more manageable. You are not being asked to predict the future with confidence. You are choosing a direction for a defined period of inquiry, with permission to revise your choice when you learn more.

A promising idea might turn out to be difficult to deliver, expensive to pursue, or less relevant to customers than you expected. An idea you set aside today might become attractive later, when your circumstances or knowledge change. Neither outcome makes the selection process a failure. The aim is to make a reasoned choice using what you know now, recognize what you do not know, and learn something useful next.

Entrepreneurs often face two decisions that sound similar but are meaningfully different.

The first is a selection decision: Which possibility is worth investigating ahead of the others?

The second is a business decision: Is there enough evidence and commitment to develop, launch, or continue this particular venture?

Selection comes before validation. At the selection stage, you may have a plausible customer, a problem you suspect matters, and an idea for an offering. You may also have relevant experience or a useful way to reach potential customers. Those are reasons to investigate, not proof that the business will work.

Validation requires learning whether the important assumptions behind an idea hold up. Depending on the idea, that may involve speaking with potential customers, examining alternatives they already use, testing an offer, or discovering what it would take to deliver the service or product. The evidence needed will vary. A short conversation can reveal that you have misunderstood a problem, but a friendly response alone does not establish that someone will buy.

This book concentrates on the decision before that work. It gives you a practical way to compare possibilities according to your circumstances and select one for further inquiry. Later, you will make a plan for that inquiry, including what you need to learn and what might cause you to reconsider.

There is a useful relief in separating these decisions. You do not need a finished business plan to compare ideas. You do need enough definition to discuss each idea honestly: whom it might serve, what problem it might address, and what you might offer. You also need a willingness to examine whether the idea fits the time, resources, experience, customer access, and risk boundaries you actually have—not the ones you hope to acquire eventually.

Consider Maya, a hypothetical aspiring entrepreneur who works in an administrative role and wants to explore a business alongside her job. She has limited spare time, some savings she is reluctant to put at risk, and experience organizing information and coordinating projects. She is interested in several directions but has not tested any of them with customers.

Maya’s three ideas form the continuing example for this book. They are not three proven opportunities; they are starting points that will become more specific as Maya works through the selection method.

Her first idea is a scheduling and administrative support service for independent home-service providers. She imagines helping small operators manage appointment requests, customer follow-ups, and routine paperwork. The work resembles tasks she has done before, although she has not yet established what these providers need most or how they currently handle administration.

Her second idea is a digital meal-planning product for busy households. Maya enjoys planning meals and has developed routines that help her own household. She imagines offering templates and practical planning materials online. She would need to learn more about creating and distributing a product, and she does not yet know which households would find her approach distinctive or useful enough to purchase.

Her third idea is an in-person plant-care service for local offices. She enjoys caring for plants and likes the idea of work that takes her away from a screen. She would need to understand the practical demands of caring for plants in different office environments, as well as the time required to travel and provide service consistently.

Each idea has an understandable appeal. The administrative service draws on Maya’s work experience. The meal-planning product connects with a personal interest and might be delivered digitally. The plant-care service offers a different kind of daily work. Each also raises questions that enthusiasm cannot answer.

Maya’s first impulse might be to ask, “Which business is best?” That question is too broad to guide her. Best for whom, under what conditions, and according to which priorities? An idea that appeals to someone with a flexible schedule and industry contacts may not be the best first investigation for Maya.

A better question is: “Given my current situation, which of these ideas has the strongest case for the…

More Business, AI & Entrepreneurship

Cover of AIAIAvailable nowCover of The New Gold RushThe New Gold RushAvailable nowCover of Leadership Intelligence for Succession PlanningLeadership Intelligence for Succession PlanningAvailable nowCover of Remote Jobs and the Scam TestRemote Jobs and the Scam TestAvailable nowCover of The Entrepreneur Mindset for Patient DecisionsThe Entrepreneur Mindset for Patient DecisionsAvailable nowCover of Price Without ApologyPrice Without ApologyAvailable now

About Todd Michael

Todd Michael is an American author and the founder of ToddMichael.tv. He writes practical, plain-English books on money, health, preparedness, technology, games, humor and more.

About the author Todd Michael · Todd Michael’s author site

Part of the ToddMichael.tv network.