Read a sample: 1. What a Mentor Can Offer
A new mentor often begins with a generous intention: I want to help someone find their way. Then the first question arrives.
“Should I apply for the role?”
It sounds like a request for an answer. The mentee may even want one. But before you decide what to say, there is more to understand. What attracts them to the role? What concerns them? What would they gain or give up? How much do they actually know about the work? And what kind of help are they asking you to provide?
Your own experience may give you a useful perspective. It may also make one option look more appealing to you than it does to them. The distinction matters. A mentor can contribute knowledge, questions, encouragement, and honest observations without taking possession of the choice.
That is the central practice of workplace mentoring: helping another person think and act with greater clarity while respecting that their career belongs to them.
You do not need to have followed a perfect career path to do this well. You do not need an answer for every question. You do need a willingness to listen, to be clear about what you can offer, and to remain curious when the mentee’s priorities differ from your own.
Workplace mentoring is a developmental relationship in which a more experienced person offers perspective and support to someone who wants to learn, grow, or navigate a work-related challenge. The experience may come from a longer career, knowledge of a particular field, familiarity with an organization, or having worked through a situation the mentee is encountering.
The relationship is centered on the mentee’s goals, though those goals do not have to be fully formed at the beginning. A mentee may arrive with a specific aim, such as preparing for a new responsibility. They may also have a less settled concern: “I know I want something different, but I can’t tell what.”
Both are workable starting points. The mentor’s role is not to supply a goal simply because the mentee is uncertain. It is to help the mentee explore what matters, notice possibilities, and decide what they want to pursue.
This does not mean the mentor sits silently while the mentee does all the work. You might explain how a process worked in your experience, point out a question the mentee has not considered, or suggest a person who could provide a different perspective. You might also respectfully challenge an assumption. The defining feature is not how much you speak; it is whether your contribution helps the mentee do their own thinking.
A useful question to keep in mind is:
Am I helping this person understand their options, or am I trying to make them choose the option I prefer?
The answer will not always be obvious. You may care deeply and still find yourself steering. Noticing that tendency is not a failure. It is an opportunity to pause and give the conversation back to the mentee.
Throughout this book, you will meet Maya, a new workplace mentor, and Jordan, her mentee. Their conversations are illustrations rather than scripts to follow word for word. Your workplace, personality, and mentoring relationship will differ, but the choices Maya faces may feel familiar.
Maya has several years of experience in operations. She has led projects, changed roles, and learned some lessons the hard way. A mentoring program has paired her with Jordan, who works on a different team and is thinking about what to do next.
Jordan is interested in a newly available project-lead role. It offers the chance to coordinate work across teams, which sounds appealing. Jordan also enjoys the technical problem-solving in their current position and is unsure whether the new role would leave enough room for it.
Maya once made a move into project leadership and found it rewarding. When Jordan mentions the opening, she feels an immediate impulse to say, “Go for it. That kind of move was great for my career.”
Her experience could be useful. But if she offers it as the answer, Jordan may feel pressure to adopt Maya’s priorities before examining their own.
Here is one way the conversation might unfold:
Jordan: There’s a project-lead opening I’m thinking about. Do you think I should apply?
Maya: I can share what that kind of move was like for me, though I don’t know yet whether it fits what you want. What interests you about it?
Jordan: I like the idea of seeing how the different teams fit together. But I’m worried I’d spend less time solving technical problems.
Maya: So the broader view appeals to you, and you’re also concerned about losing work you enjoy. Is that right?
Jordan: Yes. I don’t know how much of the job is coordinating and how much is still hands-on.
Maya: That sounds like something worth finding out before you decide. Who could give you a realistic picture of the role?
Maya does not withhold her experience or pretend that every option is equally attractive. She recognizes that her story is only one piece of information. By asking and listening first, she helps Jordan identify a missing fact that could matter to the decision.
Jordan might eventually apply, decide against it, or explore a different kind of opportunity. Maya’s contribution is not measured by whether Jordan makes the choice she would make. It is measured, in part, by whether Jordan leaves better…