Everyday Guidebooks
Cover of Resume Reading for Hiring Managers

Business, AI & Entrepreneurship

Resume Reading for Hiring Managers

A Practical Guide to Evaluating Evidence, Comparing Candidates, and Asking Better Follow-Up Questions

by Todd Michael

Available now

A polished resume can be persuasive. A sparse one can be easy to overlook. Neither tells you everything you need to know about a candidate.

Resume Reading for Hiring Managers gives you a practical way to look beyond presentation and focus on evidence that matters for the job. Starting with a role's actual requirements, you'll learn to create review criteria, examine experience and accomplishments, recognize claims that need context, and record decisions consistently across a candidate pool.

Through realistic examples and adaptable tools, you'll practice turning vague statements into fair, useful follow-up questions. You'll also see how to handle career changes, employment gaps, unfamiliar titles, and different resume formats without jumping to conclusions.

Whether you hire occasionally or review resumes every week, this guide will help you make your resume reading more focused, consistent, and ready for the next conversation.

Contents
  1. 1. What a Resume Can and Cannot Tell You
  2. 2. Start With the Work, Not the Resume
  3. 3. Build a Consistent Review Tool
  4. 4. Read for Relevant Experience
  5. 5. Make Sense of Skills and Credentials
  6. 6. Examine Accomplishments Without Guessing
  7. 7. Spot Claims That Need Context
  8. 8. Read Different Career Paths Fairly
  9. 9. Look Beyond Format and Polish
  10. 10. Turn Uncertainty Into Follow-Up Questions
  11. 11. Compare Candidates on the Same Criteria
  12. 12. Reduce Bias in the Review Process
  13. 13. Practice With Complete Resume Examples
  14. 14. Put the Process to Work
  15. Other Books by Todd Michael

Read a sample: 1. What a Resume Can and Cannot Tell You

A resume arrives looking like an answer. It has a name at the top, a sequence of jobs, and a collection of skills and accomplishments arranged to make a case. You may be tempted to make a quick judgment: promising, probably not, or exactly what we need.

But a resume is better understood as the beginning of an inquiry. It is a candidate’s selected account of experience, prepared for an audience and compressed into a limited space. It can show you where relevant work may have occurred and what the candidate says they contributed. It cannot show you the full circumstances of every job, reveal a person’s motives, or guarantee how they will perform on your team.

That limitation does not make resume review pointless. It makes the purpose of the review more specific: to identify job-related evidence, distinguish that evidence from what remains unknown, and decide what deserves a closer look. The immediate question is rarely, “Is this the best person for the job?” A more useful question is, “Based on the information available, is there enough relevant evidence to continue the conversation?”

The distinction matters because hiring managers often have to make decisions before they have complete information. A disciplined review does not remove that uncertainty. It helps you handle uncertainty without quietly filling the gaps with assumptions.

Imagine that you need someone to coordinate customer orders. The work includes keeping records accurate, communicating with customers about changes, and working with colleagues when an order is delayed.

One applicant’s resume says:

> Coordinated order updates with customers and warehouse staff, maintaining order records and resolving routine discrepancies.

That statement is relevant. It describes work that appears similar to part of the job. It also leaves plenty unanswered. How many orders did the person handle? What counted as a routine discrepancy? Did the applicant make decisions independently, or pass issues to someone else? How accurate were the records? The resume does not tell you.

A useful note might read: “Reports coordinating customer and warehouse updates and maintaining order records; scope and independent responsibility unclear.” That note preserves both the evidence and its limit.

An unhelpful note would be: “Experienced order coordinator who can independently manage complex exceptions.” The resume may eventually support that conclusion, but the statement alone does not establish it.

The reverse mistake is possible too. You might think, “They only handled routine issues, so they cannot manage complex exceptions.” That is also a guess. The candidate may have handled more difficult situations that did not make it onto the page, or may have the judgment to learn them. You do not know yet.

Resume review therefore involves two habits at once: take relevant statements seriously, and avoid making them carry more weight than they can support.

When reading a resume, separate three things:

- The observation: What does the document actually say or show? - The interpretation: What might that information suggest about the candidate’s relevance to the role? - The unresolved question: What would you need to learn before drawing a stronger conclusion?

Suppose a resume lists experience preparing weekly reports for a sales team. The observation is that the candidate reports preparing those reports. The interpretation may be that they have worked with recurring information needs and deadlines. The unresolved questions might concern the tools used, the source of the data, and whether the candidate checked the reports for accuracy.

This separation may seem deliberate for a task often performed quickly, but it prevents a familiar slide from evidence into certainty. “Prepared reports” becomes “excellent analyst.” “Worked at a well-known company” becomes “high performer.” “Changed jobs” becomes “not committed.” Each conclusion adds information the resume itself may not contain.

The same caution applies to favorable and unfavorable impressions. A polished accomplishment can attract attention, but its presence does not automatically prove the candidate was chiefly responsible for the result. An awkwardly phrased bullet can create doubt, but it does not automatically prove the candidate lacks the underlying skill.

You are not required to treat every claim as equally persuasive. A specific description of work directly related to the role generally gives you more to examine than a broad claim such as “results-oriented professional.” The point is to be precise about why one statement is useful and what it still does not establish.

Candidates often list skills because the resume format invites them to do so. “Project management,” “data analysis,” and “customer service” may all appear in a skills section. Those phrases tell you that candidates present the skills as part of their background. By themselves, they do not show how the skills were used or at what level.

Context makes the claim more useful. Compare these hypothetical statements:

- “Skilled in project management.” - “Coordinated schedules and tracked open tasks for a product launch involving sales, operations, and customer support.”

The second gives you a clearer picture of activity and setting. It still does not establish whether the person set the project plan, managed a budget, or resolved competing priorities. If those responsibilities matter to your opening, they are suitable follow-up topics.

Similarly, an accomplishment can be relevant without answering every question about ability. A candidate might state that they helped shorten an onboarding process. That suggests involvement in an improvement effort. It does not, on its own, tell you what the candidate changed, how the result was assessed, or whether the same approach…

More Business, AI & Entrepreneurship

Cover of AIAIAvailable nowCover of The New Gold RushThe New Gold RushAvailable nowCover of Leadership Intelligence for Succession PlanningLeadership Intelligence for Succession PlanningAvailable nowCover of Remote Jobs and the Scam TestRemote Jobs and the Scam TestAvailable nowCover of The Entrepreneur Mindset for Patient DecisionsThe Entrepreneur Mindset for Patient DecisionsAvailable nowCover of Price Without ApologyPrice Without ApologyAvailable now

About Todd Michael

Todd Michael is an American author and the founder of ToddMichael.tv. He writes practical, plain-English books on money, health, preparedness, technology, games, humor and more.

About the author Todd Michael · Todd Michael’s author site

Part of the ToddMichael.tv network.