Read a sample: 1. Health Benefits as a Personal Finance Decision
A workplace health plan can feel like a collection of unfamiliar terms attached to a deadline. You may be asked to choose among several options, decide whom to cover, and commit part of every paycheck before you know what care your household will need.
The decision is more manageable when you see it for what it is: a personal finance choice with health care consequences. Your selection affects your take-home pay, the bills you may face when you receive care, and the amount of uncertainty your budget can absorb. It can also affect which doctors you can see conveniently and how easily you can obtain a prescription.
You do not need to predict every illness or become an insurance expert before enrolling. You do need a workable picture of the costs you can anticipate, the expenses you cannot predict, and the documents that explain how each plan handles them. This chapter gives you a starting point for gathering that information and connecting it to your household finances.
When an employer offers health coverage, the amount you pay is often only part of the plan’s total premium. Your employer may contribute toward the rest. That contribution is a benefit, even though it may not appear in your bank account as wages.
The portion you pay is commonly deducted from your paycheck. Those deductions reduce the money available for rent, groceries, debt payments, savings, and everything else your household budget must cover. A plan with a lower paycheck deduction can leave more room in the budget today. A plan with a higher deduction may offer lower costs when you use covered care, although that is not guaranteed.
For a hypothetical example, suppose one employee-only plan costs $80 per paycheck and another costs $120 per paycheck. If the employee receives 26 paychecks during the year and the deduction applies to each one, the first plan costs $2,080 in annual premiums, while the second costs $3,120. The difference is $1,040 over the year.
That comparison is useful, but it is not a verdict. The employee is not necessarily better off choosing the first plan simply because its premiums are lower. The second plan might have a lower deductible, lower charges for frequently used services, a more useful provider network, or prescription coverage that better fits the household. It might also have features that are less attractive. The point is to compare the premium difference with what each plan offers in return.
Pay attention to the number of deductions your employer actually uses. Being paid twice a month is not the same as being paid every two weeks, and some employers handle benefit deductions differently across pay schedules. Chapter 3 will walk through annual premium calculations in more detail.
The premium is the amount paid for coverage, whether or not you receive care during a particular month. When you use care, other costs may apply. The terms can be intimidating at first, so begin with a simple map:
- A deductible is an amount you may have to pay for covered services before the plan begins paying for certain costs, subject to the plan’s rules.
- A copayment, or copay, is a fixed amount you may owe for a covered service.
- Coinsurance is a percentage of the applicable allowed amount you may owe for a covered service.
- An out-of-pocket maximum is a limit on certain eligible cost sharing during a plan period. Premiums generally do not count toward it, and other charges may be outside its protection.
These pieces do not always apply in the same order. A plan may cover some services before you meet the deductible, charge a copay for certain visits, or apply different rules to prescriptions. An out-of-network service or an excluded service can create costs that are not captured by the in-network out-of-pocket maximum.
For now, remember that the amount taken from your paycheck is only one part of the financial picture. The plan’s rules determine what may happen when you need care. Later chapters will examine each term separately before bringing them together.
A useful way to approach health coverage is to separate your regular budget from your care budget.
Your regular budget includes the premium deductions you expect as long as you remain enrolled under the same terms. These costs are relatively predictable. You can compare them with your pay schedule and other recurring obligations.
Your care budget is less predictable. It includes what you may pay for appointments, tests, prescriptions, procedures, and other services. Some expenses may be familiar, such as a recurring prescription. Others may appear with little warning.
Imagine a hypothetical household considering two plans. Plan A costs $2,400 in annual premiums, and Plan B costs $3,600. Plan A therefore costs $1,200 less in premiums for the year. If the household expects only a few routine services, that difference may be important. But if Plan A requires the household to pay substantially more for the care it uses, some or all of the premium savings could disappear.
The reverse is also possible. Paying an extra $1,200 in premiums for Plan B does not ensure that the household will save $1,200 in care costs. If little care is needed, the additional premium may be money spent for financial protection and plan features rather than for services actually used.
Neither outcome makes a choice foolish. Insurance decisions involve both expected costs and the ability to…