Everyday Guidebooks
Cover of How to Understand Investing Returns

Money, Investing & Precious Metals

How to Understand Investing Returns

A Beginner's Guide to Gains, Losses, Percentages, Inflation, and What Your Money Really Earns

by Todd Michael

Available now

A rising account balance doesn't always mean your investments performed well. A falling price doesn't tell the whole story, either.

If you've searched for "how to understand investing for beginners," this guide offers a practical place to start: understanding the returns you see. Todd Michael walks you through the numbers behind investment performance using approachable explanations and worked examples you can follow with a calculator.

Learn how price return differs from total return, why an unrealized gain isn't the same as a realized gain, and how inflation can shrink an apparently positive result. See why a 50 percent loss takes more than a 50 percent gain to recover, how deposits and withdrawals complicate account comparisons, and where fees fit into the picture.

Whether you're reviewing a brokerage statement or evaluating a performance claim, you'll finish with a clearer, more realistic way to read the numbers.

Contents
  1. 1. What an Investment Return Measures
  2. 2. From Dollars to Percentages
  3. 3. Price Return: The Change You Can See
  4. 4. Total Return: Adding the Missing Cash
  5. 5. Unrealized and Realized Gains and Losses
  6. 6. Why Percentages Can Mislead
  7. 7. Losses and the Road Back
  8. The Gap Between a Loss and Recovery
  9. A Larger Loss Creates a Steeper Climb
  10. A Formula You Can Use
  11. Define What “Break Even” Means
  12. The Order of Returns
  13. When Money Moves, the Sequence Can Matter More
  14. A Deposit Can Restore a Balance Without Recovering a Loss
  15. Losses, Distributions, and the Recovery Target
  16. Recovery After a Sale
  17. A Recovery Percentage Is Not a Recovery Date
  18. Breaking Even in Dollars Is Not the Whole Picture
  19. 8. Returns Across Multiple Years
  20. 9. Deposits, Withdrawals, and Your Personal Result
  21. 10. Nominal Return and Inflation
  22. 11. Fees, Taxes, and What You Keep
  23. 12. Reading Your Account Statement
  24. 13. Comparing Returns Fairly
  25. 14. Your Return-Reading Toolkit
  26. Case Study 1: A Positive Price Change Is Not the Whole Return
  27. Case Study 2: A Growing Balance, but a Modest Investment Gain
  28. Case Study 3: A Recovery That Has Not Reached Break-Even
  29. A Repeatable Checklist for Performance Claims
  30. Formula Reference
  31. Using a Calculator Without Losing the Meaning
  32. Practice Questions and Worked Answers
  33. The Question Behind the Number
  34. Other Books by Todd Michael

Read a sample: 1. What an Investment Return Measures

Imagine opening an investment account statement and seeing a balance of $5,400. Is that good news?

Perhaps. If the account started with $5,000 and nothing else happened, the value has increased by $400. But if you deposited another $1,000 during the period, the same ending balance tells a different story: the account holds less than the total amount you put in. If you withdrew money, received cash outside the account, or paid fees, those details matter too.

An investment return is a way to describe how an investment performed over a period of time. It can be expressed in dollars, as a percentage, or both. The useful question is not simply, “Did the balance go up?” It is, “What happened to the money invested, over what period, and what is included in the result?”

This chapter gives you a foundation for answering that question. You do not need advanced math. You do need a clear starting point, a clear ending point, and a habit of noticing when money moves in or out along the way.

Every return describes a journey between at least two points in time. The beginning and end may be a day apart, a year apart, or separated by many years. Without those points, a performance figure is incomplete.

Consider this hypothetical example:

- On January 1, you invest $1,000. - On December 31 of the same year, the investment is worth $1,080. - You made no additional deposits or withdrawals, received no cash distributions, and paid no separate fees during the period.

The starting value is $1,000: the value at the beginning of the period being measured. The ending value is $1,080: the value at the end of that period.

Because no other money moved in or out, the dollar change is straightforward:

$1,080 ending value − $1,000 starting value = $80 gain

A gain means the measured result is positive. In this example, the investment is worth $80 more at the end than it was at the beginning. A loss is a negative result: if the same hypothetical investment ended at $920 instead, it would have a dollar loss of $80.

The word value matters here. The ending value might be the amount shown on a statement, based on a market price. It does not necessarily mean you sold the investment or received cash. Until a sale or another transaction changes the situation, an increase or decrease in market value is generally described as unrealized. We will examine the distinction between unrealized and realized results in Chapter 5.

A starting value is not always the original amount you paid. If you are measuring this year’s performance for an investment you purchased years ago, the starting value for that measurement is generally its value at the beginning of this year. Your original purchase price answers a different question: how the investment’s value compares with what you paid.

In the hypothetical example, the investment gained $80. That is useful information, but it is hard to judge without knowing how much was invested.

A percentage relates the gain or loss to a starting amount. With no other cash flows in this simple example, divide the $80 gain by the $1,000 starting value:

$80 ÷ $1,000 = 0.08, or 8%

The hypothetical investment therefore had an $80 gain and an 8% return for the year. Those are two ways of describing the same basic result. The dollar figure tells you how much the value changed; the percentage tells you how large that change was relative to the starting value.

Now compare two hypothetical investments over the same period:

- Investment A starts at $1,000 and gains $80. Its return is 8%. - Investment B starts at $10,000 and gains $500. Its return is 5%.

Investment B produced the larger dollar gain, but Investment A had the higher percentage return. Neither statement contradicts the other. They answer different questions.

This distinction becomes important whenever you compare account statements, discuss results with someone else, or read a performance claim. A dollar gain may reflect a large starting balance as much as a strong percentage result. A high percentage may sound impressive while representing a modest dollar amount if the starting investment was small.

The same principle applies to losses. In a hypothetical account that starts at $1,000 and ends at $920, the $80 loss is 8% of the starting value. In an account that starts at $10,000, an $80 loss is 0.8% of the starting value. Identical dollar losses can have very different proportions.

Chapter 2 will give you more practice calculating percentages. For now, remember the essential relationship: a percentage needs a base. When someone says an investment gained or lost a certain percentage, ask, “A percentage of what starting value?”

An account balance is a snapshot. It shows what the account is worth at a particular moment, but it does not explain every reason the amount changed.

Some changes come from investment performance. Prices may rise or fall, and investments may pay distributions such as dividends or interest. Other changes occur because you move your own money into or out of the account. These movements are commonly called cash flows.

For this book, when discussing an investment account as a whole, a deposit from your bank account is money flowing into the account, and a withdrawal to your bank account is money flowing out. They change the account balance,…

More Money, Investing & Precious Metals

Cover of The Practical Gold BookThe Practical Gold BookAvailable nowCover of The Practical Gold Book, Volume 2The Practical Gold Book, Volume 2Available nowCover of The Practical Silver BookThe Practical Silver BookAvailable nowCover of The Practical Crypto BookThe Practical Crypto BookAvailable nowCover of Shielding Your WealthShielding Your WealthAvailable nowCover of Personal Finance AdvancedPersonal Finance AdvancedAvailable now

About Todd Michael

Todd Michael is an American author and the founder of ToddMichael.tv. He writes practical, plain-English books on money, health, preparedness, technology, games, humor and more.

About the author Todd Michael · Todd Michael’s author site

Part of the ToddMichael.tv network.