Everyday Guidebooks
Cover of How to Develop Leadership Through After-Action Reviews

Business, AI & Entrepreneurship

How to Develop Leadership Through After-Action Reviews

A Practical Guide to Learning From Volunteer Events Without Blame

by Todd Michael

Available now

A volunteer event can be a success and still leave you wondering what to do differently next time. A short after-action review gives your team a practical way to find out—without putting anyone on trial.

Written for volunteer coordinators and community event leaders, this guide shows you how to gather useful observations while the details are fresh, build a shared timeline, explore why things happened, and agree on a few achievable improvements. You’ll find sample questions, meeting scripts, ways to include volunteers who could not attend, and simple follow-up tools for the next event.

Whether you’re searching for leadership how to develop or looking for a better way to debrief your team, you’ll learn by practicing: listening carefully, handling disagreement, sharing responsibility, and turning lessons into action. Make each event an opportunity to grow as a leader and help volunteers do their best work.

Contents
  1. 1. Leadership Lessons Hidden in Volunteer Events
  2. 2. Choose the Right Review
  3. 3. Prepare Without Overcomplicating
  4. 4. Create Conditions for Candor
  5. 5. Reconstruct What Happened
  6. 6. Invite the Voices You Might Miss
  7. 7. Name What Worked and What Was Difficult
  8. Return to the Event’s Intentions
  9. Give Successes Their Own Space
  10. Describe Difficulties Without Reaching for a Verdict
  11. Move From Labels to Examples
  12. Separate the Experience From the Explanation
  13. Look at the Event From More Than One Position
  14. Handle Praise and Frustration With Equal Care
  15. Capture the Learning Without Solving Everything
  16. 8. Find Contributing Causes
  17. 9. Keep Disagreement From Becoming Blame
  18. Disagreement Is Information, Not a Verdict
  19. Interrupt the Label, Preserve the Concern
  20. When Frustration Enters the Room
  21. Protect the Person Who Feels Accused
  22. Apply the Same Standard to Yourself
  23. Move From Positions to the Sequence
  24. Recognize When the Group Review Is Not Enough
  25. Make a Useful Record Without Naming a Culprit
  26. Close the Conversation Without Forcing Harmony
  27. 10. Turn Insights Into Choices
  28. 11. Assign Follow-Up That Gets Done
  29. 12. Lead a Review in Twenty Minutes
  30. 13. Apply the Method to Different Events
  31. 14. Carry the Learning Into the Next Event
  32. Other Books by Todd Michael

Read a sample: 1. Leadership Lessons Hidden in Volunteer Events

The last box is packed, the tables are folded, and the volunteers who can stay late are beginning to look at the door. You have a list of things to put away, a few messages to answer, and a vague sense that the event went well—except for the parts that did not.

This is an easy moment to skip past. You may be relieved that the event happened at all. Perhaps you have already made a mental note to change the sign-in process next time. Perhaps you heard a volunteer say that the supply table was confusing, but there was no chance to ask what they meant. By tomorrow, other work will compete for your attention, and the details that felt obvious today will begin to blur.

A short after-action review gives those details somewhere to go. It is a deliberate conversation about what the team intended, what actually happened, what helped or hindered the work, and what to carry forward. It is not a search for the person who made the most visible mistake. It is a way to learn from an event while the experience is still close enough to examine.

For a volunteer coordinator, that conversation does two jobs. It can improve the next event, and it can develop the person leading it. When you invite observations you did not expect, resist a quick answer, and help a group make a realistic decision, you are practicing leadership in the middle of ordinary work.

You do not need a perfect event, a formal evaluation system, or a title that makes everyone defer to you. You need a useful question, enough curiosity to hear the answer, and a way to follow through on what the group learns.

Consider a hypothetical neighborhood resource fair held several times a year. Local organizations set up tables, residents come to find information and supplies, and volunteers welcome visitors, answer questions, and help with setup and cleanup. The coordinator, Maya, has a small planning team and a changing mix of experienced and first-time volunteers.

At the latest fair, the room was busy and the participating organizations were glad to meet residents. A volunteer at the entrance noticed that several visitors hesitated because they could not see where to begin. Another volunteer saw a line form near a table that was not prepared for the early rush. Later, a first-time volunteer spent much of a shift looking for the person who could answer a question about restocking.

From Maya’s position near the center of the room, the fair seemed lively but mostly under control. She saw the line, but it had shortened by the time she reached it. She did not notice the uncertainty at the entrance. The volunteer looking for restocking guidance eventually found someone, so Maya never heard about the delay.

None of these views is the whole event. Each is a view from a particular place, at a particular time, with access to particular information. A coordinator who relies only on their own impression may miss a problem. A coordinator who treats one frustrated comment as the entire truth may overcorrect in another direction.

Maya’s opportunity is not to collect every opinion and obey them all. It is to help the team assemble a more useful picture.

She might begin with a brief review question: “What did we want visitors and volunteers to experience today?” Someone says visitors should have been able to find the right tables without feeling lost. Another says volunteers should have known where to go for help. Those intentions become reference points for discussing what happened, rather than vague standards the team invents after the fact.

Then Maya asks for examples. The entrance volunteer describes visitors pausing just inside the door. The first-time volunteer explains that the written instructions named a contact person but did not say where that person would be. A setup volunteer adds that the welcome sign had been placed where it was easy to attach, not where arriving visitors would naturally look.

The group now has something more useful than “communication was bad.” It has observations that can be examined and tested. The sign’s placement may have contributed to visitor confusion; the contact instructions may have made it harder for volunteers to get answers. Neither explanation needs to be treated as certain simply because it sounds reasonable.

The fair also gave the team practices worth preserving. A volunteer might point out that experienced helpers introduced themselves to newcomers before the doors opened. A participating organization might have appreciated a clear setup message sent in advance. If the review only hunts for problems, the team can accidentally discard the habits that made the event work.

An after-action review is distinct from a casual debrief, even though it can feel informal. Friends and coworkers often talk after an event: “That was hectic,” or “I think people had a good time.” Such comments can be valuable, but they do not always lead to shared understanding or action.

A useful review gives the conversation a little structure:

- Intentions: What were we trying to make happen? - Experience: What happened, including what worked well? - Understanding: What conditions or decisions may have contributed? - Choices: What should we repeat, change, or examine further? - Follow-through: Who will take the next step, and when will it be checked?

These are not rigid stages that require a long meeting. They…

More Business, AI & Entrepreneurship

Cover of AIAIAvailable nowCover of The New Gold RushThe New Gold RushAvailable nowCover of Leadership Intelligence for Succession PlanningLeadership Intelligence for Succession PlanningAvailable nowCover of Remote Jobs and the Scam TestRemote Jobs and the Scam TestAvailable nowCover of The Entrepreneur Mindset for Patient DecisionsThe Entrepreneur Mindset for Patient DecisionsAvailable nowCover of Price Without ApologyPrice Without ApologyAvailable now

About Todd Michael

Todd Michael is an American author and the founder of ToddMichael.tv. He writes practical, plain-English books on money, health, preparedness, technology, games, humor and more.

About the author Todd Michael · Todd Michael’s author site

Part of the ToddMichael.tv network.