
How to Be a Good Tutor When a Student Is Stuck
Practical Questions, Graduated Hints, and Independence Checks for More Effective Tutoring
by Todd Michael
Available nowWhen a student says “I don’t know,” it can be tempting to explain the whole answer. But the most helpful response starts with finding out what is actually getting in the way.
If you’re wondering how to be a good tutor, this practical guide gives you a clear process for navigating stuck moments. Learn to distinguish a missing prerequisite from a misunderstanding or an unclear direction, then select a hint that offers enough support without doing the work for the learner.
Inside, you’ll find sample questions for opening up a stalled conversation, graduated hints for common tutoring situations, and short examples across reading, writing, and math. You’ll also learn how to check whether a student can take the next step independently—and what to try when the first approach doesn’t work.
Whether you’re new to tutoring or looking to sharpen your sessions, you’ll leave with language and strategies you can use right away.
Contents
- 1. What a Stuck Moment Can Tell You
- The Tutor’s Role: Help Without Taking Over
- One Silence, Three Different Needs
- Three Possible Sources of Difficulty
- Why the Distinction Matters
- What a Stuck Moment Does—and Does Not—Prove
- More Than One Thing Can Be True
- A Preview of the Work Ahead
- A Better First Interpretation
- 2. Pause Before You Explain
- 3. Ask Questions That Reveal Thinking
- 4. Find the Missing Prerequisite
- 5. Uncover a Misunderstanding
- Look for the idea behind the answer
- Separate an incomplete skill from a misapplied idea
- Use a contrast that puts the idea to work
- Respond to the thinking without judging the learner
- Reading: Test an interpretation against the text
- Writing: Make the missing link visible
- Help the learner revise, then check the revision
- 6. Make the Direction Clear
- 7. Choose a Response When the Cause Is Uncertain
- 8. Build a Ladder of Hints
- 9. Model Briefly, Then Hand It Back
- 10. Check for an Independent Next Step
- 11. Stuck in Reading
- 12. Stuck in Writing
- 13. Stuck in Math
- 14. Plan the Next Session
- Other Books by Todd Michael




