Everyday Guidebooks
Cover of Dividends or Growth?

Money, Investing & Precious Metals

Dividends or Growth?

A Practical Comparison of Income, Total Return, Taxes and Your Investing Goals

by Todd Michael

Available now

If you have searched for dividend investing vs growth, you have probably encountered confident claims that one approach is the obvious winner. The more useful question is: which mix of income, risk and potential appreciation fits your life?

Dividends or Growth? gives you a balanced way to compare the choices. You will learn how cash distributions and price changes combine into total return, what happens when dividends are reinvested, and why a high yield or a fast-growing business is not automatically a bargain. Worked examples also explore selling shares for cash, valuation, taxes and the trade-offs of holding both styles.

With decision worksheets and scenarios for different cash needs, this guide helps you ask better questions before you buy or change course. There is no promised winner here—just a framework for making a more informed decision.

Contents
  1. 1. The Choice Behind the Question
  2. 2. Where Investment Returns Come From
  3. 3. How Income-Oriented Investing Works
  4. 4. How Growth-Oriented Investing Works
  5. 5. Reinvesting the Cash
  6. 6. Price Changes and the Dividend Trade-Off
  7. 7. Turning a Portfolio Into Spending Money
  8. 8. Valuation: What Are You Paying?
  9. 9. Risks Hidden by the Labels
  10. A Dividend Is a Decision, Not a Guarantee
  11. Growth Can Disappoint in More Than One Way
  12. Price Volatility Is Only One Kind of Risk
  13. Concentration Can Hide Inside a Strategy
  14. The Risk of Depending on One Outcome
  15. Inspecting an Investment: A Practical Checklist
  16. Comparing Two Imperfect Choices
  17. Risk After Taxes and Costs
  18. 10. Taxes and Account Choices
  19. 11. Funds, Individual Stocks and Overlap
  20. 12. Three Cash-Need Scenarios
  21. 13. Build Your Decision Framework
  22. 14. Monitor, Rebalance and Stay Flexible
  23. Other Books by Todd Michael

Read a sample: 1. The Choice Behind the Question

Imagine opening your brokerage account and seeing two investments. One regularly pays cash into the account. The other pays little or nothing, but its supporters expect the underlying businesses to expand. Both sound useful. One appears to offer income; the other appears to offer growth.

Which one should you choose?

The answer starts with a different question: What do you need the investment to do?

If you need money for spending, a cash payment may seem like the obvious choice. If your goal is many years away, you may be drawn to companies that reinvest heavily in their businesses. Yet neither description tells you enough. A dividend-paying investment can fall in price. A company can grow while its stock disappoints. And an investor who receives no dividend can still obtain cash by selling shares—although selling introduces its own decisions and risks.

The choice between dividends and growth is not a contest between money now and money later. It is a comparison of how investments may produce returns, how those returns reach you, and what happens when your plans meet an uncertain market.

This book will help you make that comparison without assuming that one approach is inherently superior. We will look at cash flow, total return, valuation, risk, taxes, and the practical work of choosing and monitoring investments. For now, the goal is simpler: understand the choice well enough to ask better questions.

An income-oriented investor gives particular attention to investments that make cash distributions. In the stock market, those distributions often take the form of dividends: payments a company makes to shareholders, commonly from resources generated by its business.

Some investors use dividends to help cover expenses. Others reinvest them, buying additional shares instead of spending the cash. The same dividend-paying investment can therefore serve different purposes depending on the person who owns it.

Income-oriented investing is broader than choosing the stock with the highest advertised yield. An investor might consider whether a business appears able to support its payments, how its shares are priced, how much of the portfolio is concentrated in a particular industry, and whether the payments arrive at useful times. A fund that focuses on dividend-paying stocks adds another layer: its holdings, expenses, and distribution practices all matter.

The appeal is understandable. Cash appearing in an account is visible and usable. It can reduce the need to decide which shares to sell for a particular expense. But a dividend is not a promise that the investment will preserve its value, and a company may reduce or stop its payments. A high yield can reflect a generous payment relative to price, but it can also reflect a share price that has fallen because investors are concerned.

Income orientation is therefore a preference about the role cash distributions play in a portfolio—not a substitute for examining the investment.

What growth-oriented investing means

A growth-oriented investor emphasizes the potential for businesses to expand and for that expansion to support higher investment values over time. Growth-oriented companies may reinvest a substantial share of their resources in operations, products, equipment, hiring, acquisitions, or other opportunities rather than distributing as much cash to shareholders.

That description does not mean every growth company pays no dividend. Nor does it mean every company that retains cash will use it effectively. Growth-oriented funds and stocks differ widely in their businesses, prices, profitability, and risks.

The investor’s hoped-for benefit often comes through a higher share price. If the shares rise, the investor can continue holding them or sell some to obtain cash. If the shares fall, however, the investor may face a loss and may need to sell more shares to raise the same amount of money.

Growth orientation is not the same as an instruction to ignore current cash flow. It means the investor places weight on future business prospects and the possibility that value will be reflected in the share price. What the investor pays for those prospects matters as much as the attractive story.

A company and its stock are related, but they are not interchangeable. A business can sell more products, increase revenue, or earn more profit. Those are measures of business performance. Your investment return depends on what happens to the value of your shares and any cash distributions you receive.

Consider a hypothetical company whose earnings improve over a year. An investor buys a share for $100. By the end of the year, despite the business’s higher earnings, the share trades for $90. Suppose the company pays no dividend during that period. The investor’s investment has declined by $10, or 10%, even though the business grew.

That outcome can occur because investors already expected substantial growth when the share cost $100. If the actual improvement falls short of those expectations, or if investors become less willing to pay a high price for future earnings, the share price can decline. Other developments can affect the price as well.

The reverse is possible: a company’s business results can weaken while its share price rises, perhaps because the results are less disappointing than investors feared. Neither example is a prediction. Each illustrates the distance between a company’s operating results and the return earned at a particular purchase price.

This distinction matters for dividend investors, too. A company may continue paying cash while its share price falls. The payment is part of the investor’s result, but it does not erase a larger decline…

More Money, Investing & Precious Metals

Cover of The Practical Gold BookThe Practical Gold BookAvailable nowCover of The Practical Gold Book, Volume 2The Practical Gold Book, Volume 2Available nowCover of The Practical Silver BookThe Practical Silver BookAvailable nowCover of The Practical Crypto BookThe Practical Crypto BookAvailable nowCover of Shielding Your WealthShielding Your WealthAvailable nowCover of Personal Finance AdvancedPersonal Finance AdvancedAvailable now

About Todd Michael

Todd Michael is an American author and the founder of ToddMichael.tv. He writes practical, plain-English books on money, health, preparedness, technology, games, humor and more.

About the author Todd Michael · Todd Michael’s author site

Part of the ToddMichael.tv network.