Everyday Guidebooks
Cover of Baking How-To

Cooking

Baking How-To: Cream Shortening and Sugar

A Practical Guide to Cookies, Frostings, and Knowing When Your Mixture Is Ready

by Todd Michael

Available now

What does “cream until light and fluffy” actually mean when you're using shortening? This practical guide takes the guesswork out of a foundational baking technique, with clear text descriptions of how the mixture should look and feel at each stage.

Whether your search started with “baking how to cream” or with a cookie dough that didn't turn out as expected, you'll learn how to prepare ingredients, judge texture, add eggs and dry ingredients, and recognize common problems. Then practice with cookies and frostings designed to build your confidence one batch at a time.

Each recipe includes variations, while straightforward comparisons explain what changes when butter replaces shortening—from mixing behavior and spread to flavor and texture. No professional equipment or prior baking experience required: just a bowl, a mixing tool, and a willingness to learn by doing.

Contents
  1. 1. Getting Ready to Cream
  2. 2. Shortening, Sugar, and the Mixing Bowl
  3. 3. Creaming Step by Step
  4. 4. Adding the Rest of the Ingredients
  5. 5. Reading and Rescuing the Mixture
  6. 6. Butter Instead: What Changes
  7. 7. First-Batch Drop Cookies
  8. Vanilla Drop Cookies
  9. Brown Sugar Drop Cookies
  10. Chocolate Chip Drop Cookies
  11. Make the First Pan Count
  12. 8. Chocolate and Spice Cookies
  13. 9. Nutty and Oat-Filled Cookies
  14. Peanut Butter Cookies
  15. Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
  16. Toasted Nut Cookies
  17. Making the Most of the Final Fold
  18. 10. Shaped and Rolled Cookies
  19. Vanilla Slice-and-Bake Cookies
  20. Pressed Sugar Cookies
  21. Rolled Sugar Cookies
  22. What the First Sheet Can Tell You
  23. 11. Soft and Chewy Cookie Variations
  24. Chewy Molasses Cookies
  25. Soft Lemon-Sugar Cookies
  26. Soft Coconut Cookies
  27. Keeping the Texture You Baked For
  28. 12. Simple Shortening Frostings
  29. Before You Begin
  30. Vanilla Shortening Frosting
  31. Chocolate Shortening Frosting
  32. Citrus Shortening Frosting
  33. Finding the Right Finish
  34. When the Bowl Does Not Look Right
  35. Holding and Using Your Frosting
  36. 13. More Frosting Flavors and Finishes
  37. 14. Your Next Batches
  38. Other Books by Todd Michael

Read a sample: 1. Getting Ready to Cream

Before the mixer starts, a little preparation makes creaming shortening and sugar easier to see, easier to control, and much less messy. You do not need a professional kitchen or a collection of specialized equipment. You need enough room to work, a bowl that stays put, accurately measured ingredients, and a way to notice how the mixture changes.

Creaming is a mixing method, not simply a command to stir until two ingredients disappear into each other. As shortening and sugar are worked together, the mixture becomes more evenly blended and often looks lighter and more aerated. Those changes help shape the texture of cookies and other baked goods. With frosting, the goal may be a smooth, spreadable mixture rather than the same look you would seek in a cookie dough. The recipe and the ingredients both matter.

This chapter gets the workspace and ingredients ready. Later, you will look closely at the mixing itself: how the bowl feels under a spatula, what the mixture looks like at different stages, and when it is time to stop.

A recipe is easiest to follow when you know where it is going. Read the ingredient list and the directions before measuring anything. Notice which ingredients are divided, which need to be softened, and whether the finished dough must chill before baking. Check the pan size, oven temperature, and any cooling instructions.

Pay particular attention to the wording around fat and sugar. A cookie recipe may ask you to cream shortening with granulated sugar and brown sugar. A frosting recipe may have you beat shortening first, then gradually add confectioners’ sugar. These methods share the idea of working fat and sugar together, but they do not always happen in the same order.

Look for preparation words attached to ingredients. “One cup chopped nuts” means the nuts are chopped before measuring. “One cup nuts, chopped” indicates measuring them before chopping. If a recipe specifies sifted flour or sifted confectioners’ sugar, notice whether the sifting happens before or after measuring. The distinction can affect how much fits into a cup.

If you plan to substitute butter for shortening, read the recipe’s butter variation before beginning. Butter contains water and milk solids as well as fat, so it does not always behave like shortening, even when the same measuring cup is used. You will have more room to explore that difference in Chapter 6.

Clear a section of counter large enough for the mixing bowl, ingredients, measuring tools, and a small landing place for used utensils. Set out a clean towel or damp cloth for quick spills. If the bowl slides while you mix by hand, place it on a folded, slightly damp kitchen towel or a nonslip mat.

Gather what the recipe calls for before opening packages. For many cookie doughs, a practical setup includes:

- A large mixing bowl for the shortening and sugar - A second bowl for combining dry ingredients - A flexible spatula for scraping the bowl - Measuring cups and spoons, or a kitchen scale - A mixing tool: a sturdy spoon, hand mixer, or stand mixer - Baking sheets and any lining specified by the recipe

For frosting, you may also want a fine-mesh sieve if the confectioners’ sugar is lumpy, along with a small spoon or measuring spoon for adding liquid gradually.

Choose a bowl with enough space above the ingredients to allow for vigorous mixing. A bowl that looks roomy when it holds only shortening and sugar may become crowded once flour, eggs, and mix-ins are added. At the same time, a very wide bowl can make a small quantity difficult to reach with a mixer’s beaters. The beaters should be able to engage the mixture without you having to chase a thin smear around the bottom.

Keep the work area dry, especially around electric equipment. Arrange the mixer cord where it will not pull taut across your workspace, and make sure the mixer is switched off before fitting or removing attachments.

You can cream shortening and sugar by hand, with a hand mixer, or with a stand mixer. Each method can produce useful results, but each gives you different information as you work.

Hand mixing is a good way to learn how the ingredients feel. A strong wooden spoon works well for pressing shortening against the side of a bowl and working sugar into it. A firm silicone spatula can help with smaller amounts, though a very flexible one may bend too much to do the heavy work comfortably.

Hand creaming takes effort and usually more time than using a mixer. It also gives you direct feedback: a firm mixture resists the spoon, while a softer, more cohesive mixture moves more readily. A bowl with a broad, stable base is helpful, and a damp towel underneath can keep it from turning as you stir.

The spoon you use to mix may not scrape the bowl as cleanly as a flexible spatula. Keep the spatula nearby so you can gather the mixture from the sides and bottom.

A hand mixer is convenient for many home-sized batches. Its beaters move through the mixture while you guide them around the bowl. Begin at a low speed, especially when sugar or flour is loose in the bowl, and increase the speed as the recipe directs.

Hold the bowl steady with your free hand if needed. Move the beaters through the mixture…

More Cooking

Cover of The Slow Cooker Vegetable GardenThe Slow Cooker Vegetable GardenAvailable nowCover of The Mediterranean Diet Seafood StarterThe Mediterranean Diet Seafood StarterAvailable nowCover of Meals for Two to Make at HomeMeals for Two to Make at HomeAvailable nowCover of The Home Kitchen Noodle TableThe Home Kitchen Noodle TableAvailable nowCover of Meals for Two to Make From One Pack of ChickenMeals for Two to Make From One Pack of ChickenAvailable nowEasy RecipesComing soon

About Todd Michael

Todd Michael is an American author and the founder of ToddMichael.tv. He writes practical, plain-English books on money, health, preparedness, technology, games, humor and more.

About the author Todd Michael · Todd Michael’s author site

Part of the ToddMichael.tv network.