Everyday Guidebooks
Cover of An Artist's Guide to Overthinking

Self-Help & Relationships

An Artist's Guide to Overthinking

Simple Prompts to Choose Your Materials, Start Creating, and Explore Without Judgment

by Todd Michael

Available now

You want to make something, but first you need the right supplies, the right idea, and a plan you can’t possibly get wrong—or so your mind insists.

An Artist’s Guide to Overthinking offers a gentler way into creative practice. Written for anyone searching for help with overthinking art for beginners, this practical guide uses text-based prompts to help you choose materials, begin a session, and explore possibilities without putting the result on trial.

Inside, you’ll find ways to narrow an overwhelming set of choices, work with whatever supplies you already have, start when you feel uncertain, and notice what interests you along the way. Flexible prompts invite you to change direction, pause, or try again without treating any choice as a test of talent.

No particular medium, artistic technique, or polished outcome is required. Bring your curiosity, make one small choice, and see where it leads.

Contents
  1. 1. When Thinking Gets Between You and Making
  2. 2. Make Room for an Unfinished Answer
  3. The space between knowing and guessing
  4. Trade the verdict for a question
  5. Choose a purpose that can fit inside today
  6. Make an experiment small enough to enter
  7. When the question still feels too large
  8. Let “I don’t know” have a next step
  9. Try an unfinished-answer session
  10. A direction, not a promise
  11. 3. Take Stock of What You Have
  12. 4. Choose Materials Without the Perfect Answer
  13. 5. Set Up a Small Invitation
  14. 6. Begin Before You Feel Ready
  15. 7. Let Curiosity Set the Direction
  16. 8. Experiment One Choice at a Time
  17. 9. Respond to the Inner Critic
  18. Notice the Moment the Language Changes
  19. Separate What Happened From What It Means
  20. Respond Without Forcing Positivity
  21. Replace the Score With a Question
  22. When Comparison Enters the Room
  23. A Short Practice: From Judgment to Next Choice
  24. Let Preference Be Specific
  25. When the Critic Keeps Talking
  26. 10. When a Choice Doesn't Feel Right
  27. 11. Work With Limits, Not Against Them
  28. 12. Look Back Without Grading
  29. 13. Build a Practice You Can Return To
  30. A Menu, Not a Schedule
  31. Choose a Few Materials You Can Return To
  32. Gather Starting Prompts That Open a Door
  33. Give Time More Than One Shape
  34. Make a Menu for Different Days
  35. Leave Yourself a Way Back
  36. Returning After a Break
  37. Let the Practice Change With You
  38. 14. Your Next Experiment
  39. Other Books by Todd Michael

Read a sample: 1. When Thinking Gets Between You and Making

You have a little time, an interest in making something, and perhaps a few supplies within reach. You imagine sitting down to draw, paint, collage, stitch, or shape something with your hands. Then the questions arrive.

What should you make? Which materials should you use? Should you learn a few basics first? Is the paper good enough, or too good to waste? Would it be better to wait until you have a clearer idea?

A question leads to another question. You look at examples, compare supplies, and consider what kind of artist you might want to be. Eventually, the time you hoped to spend making has passed. You may even feel tired, despite having made nothing you can point to.

If this sounds familiar, you are not alone, and you have not failed a test of creativity. Thinking is part of making. It helps you notice possibilities, solve problems, and choose a direction. Trouble can arise when thinking becomes the only part of the process you allow yourself to do.

This book is an invitation to make room for both thought and action. You do not need to become a person who never hesitates. You can learn to notice when a decision is asking for more attention than it needs, then choose a small way to continue.

For now, you do not need to buy anything, organize a studio, or decide what kind of artist you are. This chapter begins with a gentler task: noticing where you tend to pause.

Imagine that Maya wants to try drawing. She has a pencil and a notebook, but she is unsure what to draw. She searches for beginner ideas and finds a long list. A cup seems possible, though she wonders if a cup is too ordinary. A plant looks more interesting, but its leaves might be difficult. She watches someone demonstrate a drawing method and realizes there are pencils with different grades. Now she wonders whether the pencil she already owns is suitable.

Maya has been engaged with drawing the whole time. Her interest is real. Some of what she found may be useful later. But if her aim was to spend a few minutes making marks, the search has carried her away from that aim.

Her loop might look like this: I want to draw; I need a good subject; I should see what beginners draw; I need better tools to draw it well; I should research tools before I begin.

Someone else’s loop may be quieter. You might set out paints and then spend the available time rearranging the colors. You might open a blank digital canvas, choose a brush, change your mind, and compare brushes until you no longer feel like working. You might have an idea, imagine how disappointing the result could be, and decide to wait for a better idea.

These loops are not evidence that you are lazy or lack discipline. Often, they are attempts to take care of something that matters to you. You may want to use limited time well, avoid wasting materials, protect yourself from disappointment, or make an experience feel manageable. Those are understandable concerns.

The difficulty is that a decision loop can promise relief without delivering it. One more comparison might seem likely to settle the question. Instead, it may introduce another option, another standard, or another reason to postpone.

Creative hesitation does not always announce itself as fear. Sometimes it sounds sensible:

- “I should find the right materials first.” - “I need a better idea before I use the paper.” - “I only have a short time, so I probably cannot do much.” - “I should understand the technique before I try it.” - “I need to know what I’m making before I start.” - “If I’m going to do this, I should do it properly.”

Any of these thoughts might contain useful information. If you have only ten minutes, it makes sense to choose something that fits. If you are using an unfamiliar material, it may be helpful to read its instructions. If a tool requires precautions, learning how to use it is part of caring for yourself and your space.

But a reasonable thought can also become a rule that is hard to satisfy. “I want to understand this material” becomes “I must understand every part of it before I touch it.” “I would like an interesting idea” becomes “I cannot begin until I know the result will be interesting.”

When you notice a thought like this, try asking:

What am I hoping this decision will protect me from?

You might discover that choosing the “right” paper seems to protect you from wasting money, or that finding the “right” idea seems to protect you from making something you dislike. Perhaps waiting for a longer block of time protects you from the frustration of being interrupted.

You do not have to argue with the answer. Simply naming the concern can make it easier to respond to the actual need. If you are worried about using expensive paper, an ordinary scrap may give you a place to explore. If interruption is likely, you might choose an activity that is easy to put down. If you are worried about disliking the result, you might begin on a page you intend to use for experiments rather than display.

The goal is not to eliminate every concern. It is to stop asking…

More Self-Help & Relationships

Cover of The Clarity BlueprintThe Clarity BlueprintAvailable nowCover of The Relationship BlueprintThe Relationship BlueprintAvailable nowCover of How a Family Caregiver Can Get PaidHow a Family Caregiver Can Get PaidAvailable nowCover of Toddler ParentingToddler ParentingAvailable nowCover of Make Room for ConfidenceMake Room for ConfidenceAvailable nowCover of Habits of Grace for Family EstrangementHabits of Grace for Family EstrangementAvailable now

About Todd Michael

Todd Michael is an American author and the founder of ToddMichael.tv. He writes practical, plain-English books on money, health, preparedness, technology, games, humor and more.

About the author Todd Michael · Todd Michael’s author site

Part of the ToddMichael.tv network.